
Environmental Racism at the Neighborhood Level
Part 2 of the Environmental Racism in Greater Boston Series
Introduction
For decades, environmental justice advocates and scholars have shown that people of color and low-income folks are more likely to live near pollution sources that are bad for their health, compared to White or high-income people.
Over time, several processes have given rise to this pattern:
Through the rise of the suburbs (see Part I of this series), Whites removed themselves from more-polluted cities and industrial areas. At the same time, highways, industry, and municipal solid waste sites are often constructed in areas with fewer resources at hand to oppose their construction. This process, known as "NIMBYism" (Not In My BackYard), allows neighborhoods with more resources to refuse placement of environmental hazards, forcing their construction in less advantaged areas. Finally, it is sometimes simply more affordable to live in more polluted areas. This means that people with fewer financial resources might choose to move into more hazardous areas.

Air Pollution
Even though air pollution is steadily improving overall in Massachusetts, a recent report found that racial/ethnic disparities in air quality are actually growing . This inequality has grown because relative improvements in air quality were greatest in areas that already have the least air pollution, like tree-lined suburbs. Those tend to be wealthy, White neighborhoods.
On the other hand, people living in more densely populated or more industrial areas have seen less improvement in air quality. People living in those areas are more likely to be low-income or people of color.
Common air pollutants include:
- Ground-level ozone - forms when nitrogen oxides (NOx) and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) react under heat and sunlight. Common sources of NOx and VOCs are anything that burns: cars, power plants, industrial smokestacks, etc.
- Particle matter (PM) - small particles that are either directly emitted from combustion sources or formed through complex chemical reactions in the air. Particles with a diameter smaller than 2.5 microns (about 5% the width of a strand of hair) are of particular concern because they can penetrate deep into the lungs. These fine particles are called PM2.5.
- Carbon monoxide (CO) - a poisonous gas that is emitted when combustion is inefficient. In cities, around 95% of the CO in the air comes from motor vehicle exhaust.
- Sulfur dioxide (SO2) - a toxic gas that results from combustion of sulfur-containing compounds. Power plants and industry are common sources of SO2.
- Nitrogen dioxide (NO2) - NO2 and other oxides of oxygen, known as NOx, are highly reactive small molecules that primarily get into the air from fuel combustion.
Most of these air pollutants come from combustion such as car/train/bus engines, waste combustion, or industrial processes.
It is important to note that air pollution does not respect administrative boundaries, and that pollution from other states can also cause health issues within Massachusetts.
Use the link below to explore how real-time indoor and outdoor air quality monitoring is being used to map local air pollution using citizen science.
Water Pollution
When water is contaminated with chemicals or bacteria, it can have a direct and harmful effect on health and well-being, especially if drinking water becomes contaminated.
Common water pollutants of concern include:
- Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances ( PFAS ): have been linked to multiple serious health harms, such as cancer and developmental and reproductive harm. Common sources include a wide variety of household objects.
- Arsenic (As) - from mining, coal-fired power plants, lumber facilities, electronics industry, foundry activities, agriculture, and natural accumulation.
- Lead (Pb) - from lead paint, mining, vehicle exhaust, construction, and agriculture. Lead is particularly harmful to healthy development in children.
- Bacteria and parasites - some bacteria and parasites, like E. coli, can cause serious illness. Common sources include agriculture and sewage.
- Pesticides - pesticides are chemicals used to kill pests (like insects and bacteria). Their health effects vary widely , from mild irritation to longer-term effects.
- Nitrates/nitrites - chemicals found in fertilizers. Can be harmful to health, especially for children under 6 months of age.
Soil Pollution
Soil can act as a 'sink' for contaminants, where small amounts of chemicals can build up to unhealthy levels over time. Runoff from roadways, leaching from landfills, and industrial waste all contribute to polluted soil. Polluted soil can harm health through ingestion of food grown in the soil, direct ingestion of soil, or inhalation of dust.
Soil contaminants of concern include:
- Lead (Pb) - from lead paint, mining, vehicle exhaust, construction, and agriculture
- Mercury (Hg) - from mining, incineration of coal, alkali and metal processing
- Arsenic (As) - from mining, coal-fired power plants, lumber facilities, electronics industry, foundry activities, agriculture, and natural accumulation
- Herbicides/insecticides - from agricultural activities
Exploring Pollution Sources
Click on the buttons below to visualize common pollution sources in Massachusetts.
More information on the Superfund program's National Priority List (NPL) can be found at the EPA's website .
Notice how pollution sources cluster together in certain areas -- how would you describe the areas where pollution clusters? Urban? Rural? Suburban?
In the next section, we will explore which populations are considered most vulnerable to multiple environmental hazards. These potentially vulnerable communities are known as 'environmental justice communities.'
Environmental Justice (EJ) communities are communities that may be particularly vulnerable to toxic environmental exposures. The term describes situations where multiple factors, including both environmental and socioeconomic stressors, may act cumulatively to affect health and the environment and contribute to persistent environmental health disparities.
Based on the data from the 2015-2019 American Community Survey, a census block group is considered EJ if it meets at least one of these criteria:
- the annual median household income is not more than 65 per cent of the statewide annual median household income;
- minorities comprise 40 per cent or more of the population;
- 25 per cent or more of households lack English language proficiency; or
- minorities comprise 25 per cent or more of the population and the annual median household income of the municipality in which the neighborhood is located does not exceed 150 per cent of the statewide annual median household income
This map shows EJ communities in Massachusetts, color-coded based on how many EJ criteria the community met: one (yellow), two (orange) or three (red).
Do you notice any patterns about EJ communities in relation to pollution sources?
What about the relationship between EJ community location and proximity to a major roadway?
Green Space and Urban Heat
Urban green space -- parks, private backyards, trees, and other foliage -- has been shown to improve air quality and produce a cooling effect, reducing urban ' heat islands '.
Green space is also good for our mental and physical health. Studies have shown that living in an area with more green space is associated with a reduced risk of death from any cause, better mental health and well-being among adolescents, and improved physical health.
Unfortunately, green space is not distributed equally. Across America's cities , neighborhoods with more people of color, lower average income, and lower education have less access to green space than higher-income, Whiter neighborhoods.
Use the dashboard below to explore the relationship between historical redlining (discussed in Part I of this series) and urban heat islands today.
Do you notice any patterns? Which areas in Boston are the hottest? Which redlining grades were these areas assigned, back in the 1930's? Which areas are the coolest, and which grades were the cool areas assigned?
Notice how areas that received an "A" grade back in the 1930's are, on average, 0.9 degrees cooler and have more tree cover than the city-wide average, while areas that received a "D" grade are on average 1 degree hotter and have less tree cover than the city-wide average. Most importantly, the same areas that received low grades from HOLC back in the 1930's are those with large populations of people of color and lower-income people-- Part I of this series explored those relationships in greater detail. While 1 degree might not seem like a large difference in temperature, that difference can get much bigger during heatwaves. Urban heat islands have been linked to an increased risk of death , especially among elderly people. On top of that, hotter urban areas can trap more air pollution, which is itself responsible for many poor health outcomes.
For these reasons, inequities in green space and tree coverage might be directly linked to health inequities through pathways related to heat, air pollution, and mental health. So, what can we do to promote "tree equity" in Boston so that all people have equal access to health-promoting green space and tree cover? Speak for the Trees , a Boston-based community organization, developed a great resource to address this question. Below, explore this resource and learn more about Speak for the Trees' work promoting tree equity in the Boston area!
Exploring Tree Equity in Boston: a StoryMap by Speak for the Trees. #TreeEquityBoston
Navigation
User Experience Survey
Resources for Community Members
Citizen Science Opportunities
Community Groups
Other Resources
Further Reading / Listening
Local
- Conservation Law Foundation - Waste Incineration is an Environmental Justice Issue . (2020) [ Disponsible en Español ]
- GBH News - Air pollution from transportation sources in Boston [read or listen] - Part I | Part II | Part III
- The Community Assessment of Freeway Exposure and Health Study (CAFEH)
National
- Environment America - Troubled Waters: Industrial Pollution Still Threatens the Nation's Waterways (2018)
- Toxic 100 Polluters Index - Air | Water | Greenhouse
- Mary Collins, Linking Toxic Outliers to Environmental Justice Communities (2016).
- The Guardian: Toxic America series.
- Michael Gochfeld, Disproportionate Exposures in Environmental Justice and Other Communities (2011).
- Richard Florida, Bloomberg City Lab - The Inequality of America's Parks and Green Space (2019).
- Jeremy S. Hoffman et al. The effects of historical housing policies on resident exposure to intra-urban heat: A study of 108 urban areas (2020).