Southwest Idaho Landscape Project

Confronting the Wildfire Crisis on the Boise and Payette National Forests

Introduction

The Forest Service has launched a robust, 10-year strategy to squarely address the wildfire crisis in the places where it poses the most immediate threats to communities. The strategy, called “Confronting the Wildfire Crisis: A Strategy for Protecting Communities and Improving Resilience in America’s Forests,” combines a historic investment of congressional funding with years of scientific research and planning into a national effort that will dramatically increase the scale of forest health treatments over the next decade.

This crisis hits close to home here in Idaho. In 2022, the lightning caused Four Corners fire threatened nearly 600 homes in the community of Cascade. This incident was a “near miss” and if weather conditions over the wildfire would have changed slightly, the outcome could have been much different. The communities near the Boise and Payette National Forests are at great risk to experience a catastrophic wildfire. The Southwest Idaho Landscape Project will focus fuels and forest health treatments more strategically and at the scale of the problem, in an effort to protect these communities.


Southwest Idaho Landscape Project

Figure 1 - SIL: vicinity map with fireshed boundaries

The Southwest Idaho National Priority Landscape Project (SIL) is one of 10 landscapes selected in this national effort. Encompassing 1.7 million acres, the SIL includes approximately 425,000 and 505,000 acres of the Boise National Forest (BNF) and Payette National Forest (PNF), respectively, and 800,000 acres of other ownership including private, state, and other federal lands.

The SIL is a landscape scale effort to reduce the risk of catastrophic and undesirable wildfire while increasing the resiliency of the landscape to climate change and other stressors. To accomplish this, the strategy is to treat at least 230,000 acres (25%) of hazardous fuels on National Forest System (NFS) lands over the next five to seven years (i.e. 2022-2028).  Treatments on NFS lands in conjunction with efforts to treat adjacent federal, state, and private land through a shared stewardship approach will aid in meeting the primary project objectives of reducing the risk of catastrophic wildfire to communities, improving watershed health, sustaining industry, protecting recreation, and improving forest resilience. 

The SIL contains all or portions of fifteen priority firesheds.  The SIL also encompasses one of two Shared Stewardship priority areas in Idaho.

Communities in the Landscape

The SIL is adjacent to or includes 14 community cores identified to have elevated risk for transboundary wildfire exposure, following the process documented in  GTR 392  and displayed in the map below. Community cores include Robie Creek, Boise City, Hidden Springs, Horseshoe Bend, Idaho City, Placerville, Garden Valley, Banks, Smiths Ferry, Cascade, Donnelly, Council, Bear, Cuprum, McCall, and New Meadows. 

The map below shows modeled wildfire hazard potential for the Southwest Idaho Landscape (source:  Wildfire Risk to Communities Wildfire Hazard Potential ). Red is very high, orange is high, yellow is moderate, and greens represent low wildfire potential.

WHP is an index that quantifies the relative potential for wildfire that may be difficult to control, used as a measure to help prioritize where fuel treatments may be needed.

The Four Corners Fire as seen from across Cascade Reservoir.


Land Ownership

Figure 2 - SIL: land ownership map

We cannot emphasize enough that this strategy represents an all-lands effort. The firesheds we have identified on the Boise and Payette National Forests cover a patchwork of ownership including private and family-owned lands, Tribal ancestral lands, lands managed by the Department of the Interior, state lands under the Idaho Department of Lands and the Idaho Parks & Recreation, as well as National Forest systems lands. As such, private and family-owned lands are an integral part of this strategy and will be critical elements in our landscape-scale planning. Within the SIL, there are about 528,000 acres of private land and about 929,000 acres of National Forest system lands.

Large wildfires and the forest management solutions know no boundaries. The Forest Service will work with all land management agencies and interested private parties to broadly manage forest and fuels across entire landscapes before wildfires occur. Our planning efforts are focused on identifying shared priorities and investing in shared capacity for this work. Under Shared Stewardship, we are working across boundaries toward shared goals to ensure all lands are more continuously managed to promote forest health and safer communities. We will also continue to build on our successes in the Collaborative Forest Landscape Restoration program and on tools and authorities like the Good Neighbor Authority and the Tribal Forest Protection Act. 


Treatments & Tools

How do fuels and forest health treatments reduce risk and improve resilience?

Land managers can increase forest resilience and minimize wildfire impacts through forest management activities based on sound science. These activities are called hazardous fuels treatments and forest health treatments because their purpose is to reduce dangerous fuel levels and to restore forests to a more natural state that can sustain itself.

Treatments include Non-Commercial Thinning and Commercial Thinning that focus on removal of trees from overstocked forests. Prescribed burns are designed to mimic the historic and natural fire regime of the forest through controlled, low-intensity burns to clear excess debris from the forest floor.  Reforestation helps to restore stressed or damaged forest to a natural and reproductive state.  These tools when used in precise ways and in targeted areas within the forest will restore forest health and resilience.    

See below for the four main tools the SIL will utilize.

Commercial Thinning

Commercial Thinning is the removal of some trees from a tree stand to give others more room to grow and thrive.  It is used to restore a more natural forest structure within the tree stand with a focus on tree density, tree species distribution, tree age distribution, and natural gaps in the canopy. 

Generally, the seral, or natural tree species within the lower to mid-elevation of the SIL area is ponderosa pine, then Douglas-fir and grand fir at mid-elevation, and lodgepole pine and sub-alpine fir at high elevations.  Over the past several decades the encroachment of fir species into the ponderosa pine ecosystem has produced a forest that is not resilient to wildfire.  Commercial Thinning will help return this resilience to tree stands while at the same time contributing to local economies.  The reduction of the number of trees reduces stress and competition in forested areas susceptible to insect, disease, and fire.

Even though harvesting timber is one method of reducing fuel continuity and subsequent potential fire behavior, the residual slash can greatly increase the surface fuel loading and subsequent risk of wildfire on harvested sites.  Because of this treatment, removal of that slash is critical in the overall process.

Non-Commercial Thinning

Non-commercial thinning of forests is a multifaceted process and often involves piling brush, pruning branches, and creating fuel breaks. Tools the Forest Service uses to thin tree stands include everything from hand tools to chainsaws and rakes, to heavy equipment.

There are two main techniques used for non-commercial thinning. The first is lop and scatter which is used to thin a forested area of smaller, less desirable trees and scatter the material, overtime this material will decompose.

The second is to thin and pile, which is simply the process of thinning out smaller, less desirable trees and/or brush in an overgrown area and piling the debris. These piles will dry naturally and then be burned during a later time when conditions are right for burning.

Thinning without prescribed fire can significantly reduce potential crown fire immediately following thinning and moderate surface modeled fire behavior beginning 2–3 years following thinning.  To extend that timeframe, prescribed fire is often used following the non-commercial thinning projects.

Prescribed Fire

It is imperative to use fire itself for fuel and forest management in our western landscapes. Fire is the essential and most effective fuel treatment to reduce wildfire risk as it produces ecological benefits that thinning alone cannot. The understanding of this is why Congress specifically targeted funding for increasing the pace and scale of prescribed burning.

While the use of prescribed fire is becoming more of a tool for other Forests across the county, the Payette and Boise National Forests have had a strong and effective history of conducting prescribed fire since the late 1980s.  It is not unusual for the two Forests to burn several thousand acres of forest land annually through the use of well-planned prescribed fire projects.

Click the link below to learn more about fuels treatments and where we are using prescribed burns.

Watch this video to learn about a fuels treatment success story on the Payette.

Watch this video to learn about a prescribed fire success story on the Payette.

Watch this video to see how prescribed fire benefits Idaho wildlife.

Watch this video to see how we keep prescribed fire within predefined boundaries.

Watch this video to see how drones support prescribed fire.

Reforestation

Reforestation is a management action to renew tree cover by establishing young trees. This work is done to maintain appropriate forest cover, achieve desired ecological conditions, and restore forests for wildlife, watersheds, and recreational experiences.

On the Boise and Payette National Forests, reforestation was effective and widely used to help in the regrowth of forest stands.  Unfortunately, as funding was reduced across Forest Service budgets, a backlog of reforestation needs has been growing across the landscape.  The Replant Act, together with forest health restoration work under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, will equate to our local Forests having the ability to catch-up on this backlog.  The Lucky Peak Nursery on the Boise National Forest will be busy in providing tree seedling as our reforestation efforts grow.

Reforestation is at the core of efforts to ensure healthy and resilient forests. Resilient forests are one of the best natural climate change solutions and are necessary to meet climate change mitigation goals.  Climate-informed reforestation, including both natural regeneration and tree planting, is vital to growing more resilient forests that will help address the wildfire crisis, sequester carbon, and enhance biodiversity and ecosystem services.

The reforestation investments made in the SIL will significantly reduce the risk of catastrophic wildfire while increasing the resiliency of the landscape to climate change and other stressors.

The Boise and Payette National Forests understand the connection that people have to public lands and as such, we are fully committed to every effort available to restore health and resiliency to the Forests.  Our intent is to restore the Forest for today’s uses and for future generations.  If you have questions regarding our effort within the Southwest Idaho Landscape, please reach out to us. 

Boise National Forest:  Mike Williamson, Public Affairs Officer, 208-373-4105,  michael.williamson@usda.gov 

Payette National Forest:  John Riling, Wildfire Crisis Strategy Project Manager, 208-215-4049,   john.riling@usda.gov 

Strategy

Management Goals for the SIL

  • Move vegetation toward the desired conditions specified in the Forest Plan to provide for ecological processes and resilience to stressors such as unplanned wildfire, climate change, and insect outbreaks.
  • Provide for the protection of life, investments, and valuable resources through appropriate vegetation, fuel, and wildfire management.
  • Mitigate wildfire threats to communities by creating control features to prepare for restoring more frequent, low-severity fire to the landscape.
  • Protect WUI communities from catastrophic fires and create strategic control features to prepare for returning a favorable fire regime to the landscape.
  • Protect water quality from deleterious effects of high severity fires.

Management Objectives for the SIL

  • Schedule and complete prescribed fires and mechanical treatments.
  • Reduce high intensity wildfire potential to enable wildfire response where suppression resources can safely access and anchor their actions with an increased likelihood of success.
  • Reduce the risk of uncharacteristic wildfire by modifying fuel accumulation.
  • Improve firefighter and public safety by treating fuels that provide access and create and/or maintain a low wildfire hazard in the urban interface.
  • Reduce the potential for undesirable effects from wildfire on the landscape.
  • Strategically locate treatments in areas to utilize future ignitions to meet resource objectives.
  • Restore fire as an ecological process in vegetative communities.
  • Improve ecosystem health, wildlife, and pollinator habitat.
  • Increase resiliency of existing vegetation communities by modifying stand structure and composition and bring into closer alignment with historical conditions.
  • Reduce ladder fuels that provide vertical and horizontal fuel continuity thereby reducing crown fire risk.
  • Increase canopy base heights and crown spacing to reduce the risk of crown fire.
  • Increase the effectiveness of all wildfire risk reduction actions by working across boundaries with all jurisdictional partners.
  • Increase capacity by allowing partners to assist with implementation to achieve shared goals.

Community Involvement is a Must

It will take a united effort to meet goals and objectives of the SIL. With the help of our partners, the Forests will be working with adjacent federal, state, and private landowners through a shared stewardship approach to protect communities and other important resources such as water supplies and habitats from the effects of catastrophic wildfires.

The  Boise Forest Coalition  and  Payette Forest Coalition  have been instrumental in helping build broad support for active management of this landscape. These coalitions are independent from the Forest Service and their help is needed more than ever to match the pace and scale of forest management needed to address the wildfire crisis in Southwest Idaho.  These coalitions bring interested parties together from across the spectrum of land management perspectives to work together in making recommendations to the Forest Service.  It is this collaborative support that has helped the Forest Service make great strides in getting work done on the ground over the past several years, and their continued involvement will support current and future efforts.  If you are interested in becoming a part of these coalitions, please contact them for additional information.


Priority Firesheds

The SIL overlaps with 15 priority firesheds, and one of two Shared Stewardship priority areas in Idaho. Seven of these firesheds will be discussed in detail which cover over 93% of the landscape, see Table 1.  Figure 1, right, displays the SIL project boundary and the fireshed boundaries. The other 8 firesheds will not be discussed in detail, as they represent less than 8 percent of the SIL, but there is a need for and will be treatments to meet the project goals and objectives.

More information on Firesheds and the Fireshed Registry can be found  here .

Table 1 - SIL: Fireshed Acreage

McCall Fireshed

The McCall fireshed is 280,400 acres. Elevations in this fireshed range from 4,900 to 8,700 feet in elevation. The fireshed is within Valley and Adams County. Valley County’s population has grown approximately 11.5% since 2018. Adams County’s population has grown approximately 10% since 2018. Much of this growth has occurred outside of incorporated communities creating an increase in the wildland urban interface. 

The primary values at risk in this fireshed include:

  • Communities of McCall, New Meadows, and Council
  • ESA listed Bull Trout habitat, Chinook Salmon, Steelhead, Northern Idaho Ground Squirrel, Lynx, Wolverine, and Whitebark Pine
  • Numerous range permits and infrastructure including Price Valley Guard Station
  • Campgrounds include Grouse, Cold Springs, Last Chance
  •  Brundage Mountain Ski resort 

Cascade Fireshed

The Cascade fireshed is 279,700 acres, of which 54 percent is managed by the Forest Service, 37 percent private lands, 3 percent State of Idaho lands, and 5 percent other public lands. The majority of this fireshed is within Valley County. Elevations in this fireshed range from 3,700 to 8,400 feet in elevation, with Fire Regime Group I being the most predominant (42%). The majority of the vegetation is departed from historical conditions, with 27% highly departed. More about Fire Regimes here:  https://www.landfire.gov/frcc/frcchome.php 

The primary values at risk in this fireshed include:

  • Communities of Cascade and Smith’s Ferry
  • ESA listed bull trout and Northern Idaho Ground Squirrel habitat
  • Numerous range permits and infrastructure
  • Significant recreation infrastructure around Lake Cascade as well as Sage Hen Reservoir. Areas surrounding Lake Cascade overlap with high-risk areas identified in Idaho Power’s  Wildfire Mitigation Plan 
  •  Tamarack Ski Resort 
  • Municipal watershed and water quality in Cascade reservoir. Sage Hen Reservoir is a critical resource for downstream irrigation in agricultural communities in Gem County, such as Emmett, ID.

Idaho City Fireshed

The Idaho City fireshed is 284,200 acres. The fireshed is entirely within Boise County, which is the highest ranked county in Idaho for wildfire risk according to Wildfire Risk to Communities ( https://wildfirerisk.org/explore/0/16/16015/).  The 1990 to 2000 average annual population growth rate of Boise County was about 9.0%. The county’s growth rate is considerably more than Idaho’s growth rate and the national average. The largest change in Boise County’s population occurred in the unincorporated portion of the county which gained more than 3,840 residents from 1990 to 2018 (source Boise County Comprehensive Plan, December 2019 update).

 The primary values at risk in this fireshed include:

  • Communities of Idaho City, Centerville, Placerville, Mores Creek (the area containing Robie Creek, Wilderness Ranch and Clear Creek) along with unincorporated private land under Boise County, Idaho jurisdiction
  • Critical Bull Trout (Salvelinus confluentus) habitat
  • Numerous range permits
  • Infrastructure (communication sites, power transmission lines, recreation sites.
  • This fireshed overlaps with numerous high-risk areas identified in Idaho Power’s  Wildfire Mitigation Plan,  where they plan to make significant investments to reduce risk through 2025. Key locations include the Robie Creek community, along Grimes Creek to Placerville and past Pioneerville to Grimes Pass.= as well as along highway 21 to Idaho City.
  •  Bogus Basin Mountain Recreation area 
  • Tributaries to the Boise River (municipal watershed)

Council Fireshed

The Council fireshed is 148,600 acres. Elevations in this fireshed range from 3,100 to 8,200 feet in elevation. The fireshed is primarily within Adams County with small portions of Valley and Washington County. Adams County population has grown approximately 10% since 2018. Much of this growth has occurred outside of incorporated communities creating an increase in the wildland urban interface.

Several large uncharacteristic large fires have impacted the fireshed within the past 10 years. 

The primary values at risk in this fireshed include:

  • Communities of Council and Indian Valley
  • ESA listed Bull Trout habitat, Chinook Salmon, Steelhead, Lynx, Wolverine, and Whitebark Pine
  • Numerous range permits and infrastructure
  • Campgrounds include Cabin Creek
  • Tamarack Ski Resort

Crouch Fireshed

The Crouch fireshed is 218,000 acres, of which 43 percent is managed by the Forest Service, 32 percent is private land, 18 percent are State of Idaho land and 7 percent other public lands. The majority of this fireshed is within Boise County. Elevations range from 2,600 to 7,300 feet and Fire Regime Group I dominates the landscape (71%). Only 8% of this fireshed has experienced wildfire in the last 10 years and it has the second largest amount of vegetation departure of firesheds in the SIL. More about Fire Regimes here:  https://www.landfire.gov/frcc/frcchome.php 

The western portion of this fireshed has been a focus for the Boise Forest Coalition since 2012 and includes projects in all phases of implementation, including the Coalitions ongoing  Citizen Science  effort.

The primary values at risk in this fireshed include:

  • Communities of Garden Valley and Banks
  • ESA listed Bull Trout habitat, Northern Idaho Ground Squirrel, Lynx, Wolverine, and Whitebark Pine
  • Numerous range permits
  • Network of campgrounds and infrastructure along the Banks-Lowman highway around Garden Valley, as well as along highway 55 (scenic byway).
  • This fireshed overlaps with high-risk areas identified in Idaho Power’s  Wildfire Mitigation Plan,  such as the Garden Valley community.

 

Bear Fireshed

The Bear fireshed is 178,900 acres. Elevations in this fireshed range from 2,800 to 8,800 feet in elevation. The Fireshed is primarily within Adams County with a small portion in Idaho County which is outside the SIL. Adams County population has grown approximately 10% since 2018. Much of this growth has occurred outside of incorporated communities creating an increase in the wildland urban interface. Other infrastructure includes main power lines running from the Hells Canyon Dam Complex and Highway 95 (main travel corridor from Northern to Southern Idaho). 

The primary values at risk in this fireshed include:

  • Communities of Bear and Cuprum and multiple subdivisions
  • Highway 95
  • ESA listed Bull Trout habitat, Chinook Salmon, Steelhead, Northern Idaho Ground Squirrel, Lynx, Wolverine, and Whitebark Pine
  • Numerous range permits and infrastructure
  • Campgrounds including Huckleberry, and concentrated undeveloped recreation sites
  • Main power supplies for the communities of McCall, Council, and surrounding area (from Hells Canyon Dam complex)

Brownlee Fireshed

The Brownlee fireshed is 220,100 acres. Elevations in this fireshed range from 1,600 to 7,900 feet in elevation. The Brownlee fireshed is primarily within Adams and Washington County. Adams County population has grown approximately 10% since 2018 and Washington County grew by approximately 4%. Much of this growth has occurred outside of incorporated communities creating an increase in the wildland urban interface. Other infrastructure includes main power lines running from the Hells Canyon Dam Complex, the Highway 71 corridor, and the Brownlee Guard Station. 

In 2020, the Woodhead fire burned approximately 50,000 acres of National Forest System lands within the fireshed.  The Woodhead fire produced mixed severity across the landscape including stand replacing in higher elevations, and low severity in lower elevation Ponderosa Pine. 

The primary values at risk in this fireshed include:

  • Communities of Cambridge and Council Idaho and multiple subdivisions 
  • Highway 95
  • ESA listed Bull Trout habitat, Northern Idaho Ground Squirrel, Wolverine, and Whitebark Pine
  • Numerous range permits and infrastructure
  • Numerous developed and undeveloped campgrounds and recreation sites

Success

What does success look like?

Success within the SIL will be defined by significantly reducing the threat of catastrophic wildfire to communities and other high value infrastructure across the landscape.   This will be accomplished by reducing tree densities, ladder fuels, and surface fuels allowing fire managers to have greater success suppressing unwanted wildland fire and protecting values-at-risk.  Success in this landscape will be calculated using standard metrics, such as acres treated, through empirical monitoring and analysis, and through modeling pre- and post-treatment outcomes. The goals will have been reached when the landscape is resilient to disturbance, communities and other highly valued infrastructure and resources can be protected from undesirable wildfire, and the communities and stakeholders within the landscape support our management actions and engage by treating their own contributing landscapes.  

Watch this video to see how fuels treatments helped save the town of Cuprum from wildfire.

Measures of Success Within the SIL

The BNF, PNF, and Intermountain Region are still working to determine the best metrics to quantify progress in the SIL.  We are exploring different options to quantify progress towards the following project outcomes/objectives:

  • Increase ability to control fire spread.
  • Reduce potential for undesirable fire effects in Ponderosa Pine.
  • Reduce potential fire size and severity.
  • Reduce pathways for fires to reach communities.
  • Reduce wildfire risk to assets.
  • Reduce wildfire risk to ecosystems.
  • Reduce wildfire risk to watersheds and water quality.

Figure 1 - SIL: vicinity map with fireshed boundaries

The Four Corners Fire as seen from across Cascade Reservoir.

Figure 2 - SIL: land ownership map

Table 1 - SIL: Fireshed Acreage