The Axolotl Conservation Paradox


What is an axolotl?

The axolotl, also known as the "Mexican walking fish", is a critically endangered salamander found exclusively in the Xochimilcho lake complex near Mexico City. Aside from their natural habitat, axolotls can be found as pets, particularly in Japan, as well as in research labs.

On average they grow to 9 inches long and are naturally dark colored but have been bred in captivity to be pink. They live anywhere from 10 to 15 years in the wild, surviving off a carnivorous diet that mainly consists of mollusks, worms, insect larvae, crustaceans, and some fish.

Axolotls have been described as "sexually mature tadpoles" since they retain their larval features throughout adult life (neoteny). Additionally, axolotls also differ from other amphibians since they live permanently in water.

The axolotl got its name from Xolotl, the Aztec god of fire and lightning. It is said that in order to avoid being sacrificed, Xolotl transformed into a salamander. The word axolotl itself translates to "water monster."

Axolotl, what is your secret?


Why is the axolotl endangered?

Map of the Valley of Mexico circa 1492 Image Source: https://www.mexicolore.co.uk/aztecs/home/water-in-valley-of-mexico

The shrinking size of the axolotl population is largely due to human activity. Prior to the introduction of large fish in their habitat, the axolotl was used to being a top predator. The introduction of another top predator upset the natural balance of the ecosystem, increasing competition for the axolotl due to an overlapping ecological niche. Even though competition is natural, the introduction of another fish species is obviously the result of human intervention.

Currently, the axolotl is only found in Lake Xochimilco. They used to be found in Lake Chalco, but all of Mexico's "great lakes" were drained with the exception of Lake Xochimilco in the 1970s for flooding prevention and urban expansion. This marked the start of direct human interaction with the axolotl through habitat destruction.

The water of Lake Xochimilco is highly contaminated. Mexico's poor waste regulations coupled with increasing tourism in Mexico City has led to a large amount of trash, including high levels of plastics and metals, dumped into the canals of Lake Xochimilco. Additionally, the lake complex is highly eutrophic, leading to algal booms and the death of animals due to oxygen deprivation.

Lake Xochimilco Image Source: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/dec/04/axolotls-in-crisis-the-fight-to-save-the-water-monster-of-mexico-city

The axolotl is extremely vulnerable since it is only (naturally) found in one area. Due to the rapid expansion of Mexico City, Xochimilco is a popular area for development for those who cannot afford to live in the city. This rapid urbanization poses a threat to the axolotl's small habitat and created more stress for they are sensitive to noise.

Axolotls were once eaten by the Aztecs, and they are still eaten today as a Mexican delicacy and can be found in a traditional syrup made for respiratory illnesses.

Axolotl population decrease since 1998. Source: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/The-Xochimilco-axolotl-population-has-declined-dramatically-over-the-last-few-years_fig2_283766634

The size of the axolotl population has exponentially declined. In 1998, a survey found that there were 6,000 individuals per square kilometer. In 2015, not even 20 years later, a recent survey found that there were 35 individuals per square kilometer. It was predicted to go extinct in the wild in 2020 (it has not).

Red pin marks the location of Lake Xochimilco and blue shows Lake Chalco in modern day Mexico.


Why is the axolotl a "conservation paradox"?

Conservation Paradox

Richard Griffith, an ecologist at the University of Kent, describes the axolotl as a "complete conservation paradox." He explains that their conservation is paradoxical since "it’s probably the most widely distributed amphibian around the world in pet shops and labs, and yet it’s almost extinct in the wild.”

Axolotl Popularity

Research

Axolotl in a lab. Image Source: https://news.northeastern.edu/2017/08/02/july-2017-in-photos/

The axolotl has been deemed the "white mice of amphibians" as they are ideal for research since they are easy to rear in the lab. Axolotls are widely studied because of their regenerative abilities and have been essential for major medical advances. Their genome is much larger than that of a human and has also been studied and broken down to pinpoint the genes that code for their heart defect and regeneration. Additionally, the axolotls used for research are highly inbred and are more vulnerable to catastrophe since there is little genetic diversity. Captive populations greatly differ from wild axolotls in both their genome and behavior since they are highly domesticated.

Axolotl limb regeneration

Dragons from Disney's How to Train Your Dragon inspired by axolotls. Image Source: https://www.pinterest.com/pin/537617274267845918/

Pop Culture

The axolotl is highly loved as is a prized pet that often appears in pop culture. Toothless, the dragon from How to Train Your Dragon, was inspired by the axolotl (as shown by the image). Dr. Axolotl appears in Disney's show TaleSpin, and another axolotl character is rumored to appear in Disney's up and coming movie Día de Muertos. Yolanda from the Netflix show Bojack Horseman is an axolotl, and it also appears in Pokemon games. Mexico prides itself on being home of the axolotl. Axolotl souvenirs are commonly sold, and they can be found in many murals painted by Diego Rivera. The axolotl is supposed to appear on the 50 peso bill starting in 2022.

Potential 50 peso bill. Image Source: https://mexiconewsdaily.com/news/axolotl-to-appear-on-new-50-peso-bill/


What conservation efforts have been proposed?

Threat 1: Non-native fish

The common carp and tilapia had been introduced into Lake Xochimilco and are partially responsible for the decline in the axolotl population. Tilapia target axolotls as juveniles and carps as eggs.

Solution 1: Shrink fish population

Paying local fishermen to catch tilapia and common carp in the areas axolotls live would allow them a window of time to reestablish themselves.

Threat 2: Contaminated water

Treatment facilities release human waste in Lake Xochimilco whenever there is a powerful storm. This is especially detrimental to amphibians since they extremely permeable skin.

Solution 2: Major infrastructure improvements

Mexico's sewer system is old and ill equipped to deal with such storms. Addressing this issue would require major investment in infrastructure from the government and is much more complicated.

Problem 3: Releasing axolotls under current conditions is pointless

Griffiths, an ecologist at the University of Kent, states that “there’s probably not much point in doing releases into the wild until you can neutralize the threats" and that doing so might increase the fish population by supplying them with more food.

Solution 3: Ecosystem management

Clearly, the first two threats hold a lot of weight and do not allow any room for population growth. Reintroduction would require diligent ecosystem management. On a positive note, past efforts have shown that lab-bred axolotls might be able to survive and breed in the wild.


What conservation efforts have been made?

The Mexican government has set aside protected areas, Ejidos de Xochimilco and San Gregorio Atlapulco Protected Natural Area, to try and conserve what was little habitat was left.

Griffiths has worked to try and increase the popularity and appreciation of the axolotl among the community in Xochimilco through education programs, workshops, public meetings, and most importantly, tourism.

Scientists are working to revitalize the use of Chinampas, floating fields composed of layered soil and twigs used for farming, which provides an additional habitat for axolotls and filters water.

The Mexican federal government provided a land grant for axolotl conservation. Filters have been added to canals to keep out predatory fish and lab-bred axolotls have been released in these areas.

The axolotl was listed as critically endangered by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature and has additional protection under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species agreement.

Overall, the Mexican government has done little to contribute to axolotl conservation, both financially and through policy, and most conservation efforts have been made by local scientists. Dr. Luis Zambrano (pictured) is a leading scientist working on axolotl conservation at the Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (UNAM).


So what can we do?

The Mexican government holds the most power over the axolotl population. Electing policymakers (in Mexico) that support axolotl conservation and who value the environmental conservation of Lake Xochimilco would be the most effective way to support the axolotl. If more people (besides scientists) were to put more pressure on the Mexican government to intervene more (through petitions, lobbying, etc.), change may be more likely to come.

Having conversation about axolotl conservation both in person and online is another way to bring awareness to the cause. Flagship species are powerful and have the potential to inspire the masses to care more about conservation and protection. As the axolotl is already well loved, it could easily become a flagship species if its dire situation was made more well known.

JavaScript is not available.

Donating to organizations that support wildlife conservation is a more indirect way to support the axolotl. Organizations like the World Wildlife Fund accept donations to fund their conservation work which often deal with endangered species like the axolotl.

Visiting Xochimilco with the intent to support the axolotl (be it through conversation with locals or by buying axolotl related souvenirs) has the potential to increase the community's appreciation of the axolotl, further pushing them to support axolotl conservation.


How can I learn more about axolotl conservation?

  • Dr. Zambrano is responsible for most axolotl conservation efforts in Xochimilco. His work is the best place to start and is easily accessible and understood by everyone since he has published research and worked with mainstream media outlets.
  • Since axolotls are common in the aquarium trade, they can often be found in zoos or aquariums. This is a great way to come in contact with an axolotl (without the commitment of owning one) and to learn more about it as a species and its conservation status and efforts.
  • BBC's Discovery has two episodes on axolotl conservation, one called "The Aztec Salamander" and the other is called "The Nun's Salamander".
  • Many YouTube videos have been made by YouTube content creators and well respected organizations on axolotl conservation. Short videos have been made by National Geographic, BBC, and the Detroit Zoo and are packed with information. An interview with Dr. Zambrano on CNN is also on YouTube.

    Map of the Valley of Mexico circa 1492 Image Source: https://www.mexicolore.co.uk/aztecs/home/water-in-valley-of-mexico

    Lake Xochimilco Image Source: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/dec/04/axolotls-in-crisis-the-fight-to-save-the-water-monster-of-mexico-city

    Axolotl population decrease since 1998. Source: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/The-Xochimilco-axolotl-population-has-declined-dramatically-over-the-last-few-years_fig2_283766634

    Axolotl in a lab. Image Source: https://news.northeastern.edu/2017/08/02/july-2017-in-photos/

    Dragons from Disney's How to Train Your Dragon inspired by axolotls. Image Source: https://www.pinterest.com/pin/537617274267845918/

    Potential 50 peso bill. Image Source: https://mexiconewsdaily.com/news/axolotl-to-appear-on-new-50-peso-bill/