Reverend Richard Bell, 1864-1865

Reverend Stephen Tasco, 1865-1867

Reverend Robert H. Robinson, 1867-1869

Reverend Nathaniel M. Carroll, 1869-1871

Reverend Warner Cook, 1871-1873

Reverend James Ockemy, 1873-1875

Reverend R. H. Robinson, 1875-1876

Reverend Phillip Scott, 1867-1877

Reverend William Cooper, 1877-1879

Reverend James Thomas, 1879-1881

Reverend Henry Carroll, 1881-1883

Reverend Perry G. Walker, 1883-1886

Reverend C.G. Key, 1886-1891

Reverend William P. Ryder, 1891-1896

Reverend John A. Holmes, 1896-1915

Reverend Robert H. Thomas, 1915-1919

Reverend Benjamin T. Perkins, 1919-1923

Reverend E.S. Williams, 1923-1928

Reverend C.Y. Trigg, 1928-1942

Reverend Fairfax F. King, 1942-1947

Reverend Ely L. Lofton, 1947-1950

Reverend Kelly L. Jackson, 1950-1956

Reverend Frank L. Williams, 1956-1968

Reverend Ernest P. Clark, 1968-1980

Reverend Dr. Irvin C. Lockman, 1980-1989

Reverend Dr. Louis Shockley, Jr., 1989-1994

Reverend Dr. Jeremiah G. Williams, 1994-2011

Reverend Dr. Michelle Holmes-Chaney, 2011-2014

Reverend Eric W. King, Sr., 2015-2017

Reverend Dr. Howard W. Hinson, 2017-2020

Reverend Rodney Hudson, 2020-present