
Frogs & Toads in the Watershed
Listen to these night sounds and find out what they mean
Exploring the watershed by listening closely
During 2019 and 2020, VLAWMO made it a priority to better understand our wetlands in a variety of ways. One way we did that was by conducting a frog and toad call survey. The survey is modeled after a long-running MN DNR sampling program and follows the same protocol. A survey consists of 3 separate sampling sessions, or runs, of an established route. In our area, Run 1 takes place between April 15-30, Run 2 takes place between May 20-June 5, and Run 3 takes place between June 25-July 10. Runs begin later in the northern part of the state because frogs and toads start calling later there.
The Survey Protocol:
A survey run begins at least 30 minutes after sunset. Warm, still, cloudy evenings are ideal, and a light rain is acceptable. Runs are not conducted if the wind speed is above 8 mph. Loud vehicle noise can obscure calls, so vehicles passing are noted. An observer listens for 5 minutes and counts all frog and toad calls that they hear. An index value is used. This allows a standardized rating of call intensity (ranging from a 1-3 possible score). We heard 8 species in the Vadnais Lake Area Watershed during our survey in 2019. We heard the same species in 2020, with some slight differences at specific locations. A single year of survey would only provide a snapshot of frog and toad diversity. With 2 years of data, we have a more solid baseline to use as we build projects and continue to manage these areas.
8 species detected during surveys:
One: Wood frog (Lithobates sylvaticus)
Two: Boreal chorus frog (Pseudacris maculata)
Three: Spring peeper (Pseudacris crucifer)
Four: Northern leopard frog (Lithobates pipiens)
Five: American toad (Anaxyrus americanus)
Six: Gray treefrog (Hyla versicolor), and Seven: Cope's gray treefrog (Hyla chrysoscelis)
These 2 species can only be distinguished from each other by their calls.
Eight: Green frog (Lithobates clamitans)
"Those who dwell among the beauties and mysteries of the earth are never alone or weary of life." -Rachel Carson

Before listening to calls recorded in our watershed, check out the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency's (MPCA) guide with individual frog and toad calls.
Vadnais Lake Area Watershed Frogs, Toads, Habitat Connections, and More:
Listen to the sounds of a spring evening at Vadnais-Sucker Lakes Regional Park (Run 1: Conducted between April 15-30)
SoundCloud Widget
Audio description: The first sound that tends to jump out for people in this recording is the high-pitched call of the Spring peeper. These frogs are surprisingly loud for their tiny size. They are also declining in metro areas because of habitat loss, especially wooded wetlands that only hold water for part of the year. Next, find the Boreal chorus frogs. Their call is often described as running a finger along a comb. Then notice the lower pitched, kind of grumbling persistent calls, like they’re doing a lot of gossiping. These calls are made by Wood frogs and are fairly continuous in this recording. Wood frogs have a distinctive black mask. They move from wetland areas to upland habitats after breeding. Connected areas between wetlands and forested areas are important for this species. They overwinter in the leaf litter in upland areas and travel back to wetlands in the spring to breed.
Hover or click on numbered sites on the map to learn more about these locations where frogs and toads were surveyed. Scroll below to learn more about highlighted sites.
Frog and toad call survey locations in the Vadnais Lake Area Watershed
Vadnais-Sucker Lakes Regional Park
Map locations #3 and #5
Vadnais-Sucker Lake Regional Park contains some of the highest quality habitat in the Vadnais Lake Area Watershed. It is owned by the St. Paul Regional Water Service and run by Ramsey County Parks. This protected area helps to ensure high-quality drinking water from East Vadnais Lake, which is the main reservoir for St. Paul and surrounding communities.
A calm afternoon on Sucker Lake, a popular fishing and relaxing spot in the park.
Vadnais-Sucker Park also has a high diversity of frogs and toads. All 8 species detected during the 2019-2020 sampling seasons were found in the park.
Vadnais-Sucker Park isn't only important to frogs and toads. Many mammal species are also be found here. Coyote activity is high. Interesting behaviors are often on display at remote-camera sites. In urban areas, coyotes tend to occupy high-quality habitats, whereas Red fox shift into residential areas. Red fox shift into these areas to avoid interacting with coyotes. Coyotes will opportunistically kill other predators, like foxes, that could compete with them for food.
River otters also use this park, as evidenced by frequent tracks and numerous latrine sites.
A pair of River otters visits a spot that a mink had recently investigated. River otters will kill mink because they feed on many of the same prey items. This is called intraguild competition and is the same as the pressure between coyotes and foxes.
Night time is survey time for calling frogs and toads. This picture was taken on the shore of West Vadnais Lake (Map location #4). Parkland connects E and W Vadnais, but W Vadnais had 6 species and weak choruses whereas E Vadnais had 8 species and strong choruses. This suggests a potential for restoration benefits at W Vadnais. West Vadnais Lake is impaired for nutrients and has poor quality wetlands that are primarily colonized by invasive species.
"An understanding of the natural world and what's in it is a source of not only a great curiosity but great fulfillment." -David Attenborough
Prime Habitat
In Vadnais-Sucker Park, there are large stands of Red pines and other conifers that were planted in partnership with the University of Minnesota many years ago. Some plants, like the Bluebead lily (photo left), are found in this park and on the very southern end of their range because of those stands of conifers. Climate change has implications for the future of these plant communities.
Star flowers and many species of fern thrive in the park. These plants can be viewed along the main road/trail to the picnic shelter. Walk carefully and stay on marked trails to avoid stepping on these fragile plants.
People often mean well but don't understand the impacts of their actions, especially when they hike off-trail in public parks. This photo shows an area that was being trampled by well-meaning explorers. A resident and local botanist alerted VLAWMO to the unintended trail that was being created. VLAWMO put a sign at the site to discourage further damage.
Healthy plant communities in wetlands and uplands are important for frog and toad survival. Frogs and toads breed in wetland areas. Many species migrate to upland areas to spend the summer. A loss of wooded wetlands in urban areas is thought to be leading to a decline in Spring peepers in the Twin Cities Metro.
Vadnais-Sucker Park is the only place we've seen Red fox with our camera monitoring in the watershed. We focus our monitoring in protected areas. If we shifted cameras into residential areas, we would expect to see Red fox more frequently. We would also take on a higher risk of camera theft due to human activity if we focused in those areas.
"A thing is right when it tends to preserve the integrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community. It is wrong when it tends otherwise." -Aldo Leopold
Listen to a summer evening in Long Marsh, North Oaks, Map location #10
(Run 2: Conducted between May 20-June 5)
SoundCloud Widget
Audio description: This recording is a little quieter than the first one. You may want to adjust your volume as you listen. Boreal chorus frogs (that sound like running your finger down a comb) and Spring peepers (loud single peeps) are present again. It's a little later in the season, so now we also hear the long, steady trill of the American toad, and the loud fluttery trill of Gray treefrogs. In this example, you can hear that the Gray treefrogs are farther off in the distance and have a strong chorus. You may not be able to separate Cope’s gray treefrogs standing out with all of the other noise. You will be able to hear them better in the next recording.
Scroll through the slideshow below to see more habitat connections
Listen to a summer evening at Tamarack Nature Center, White Bear Township, Map location #13
SoundCloud Widget
Audio description: These calls were recorded at the small wetland area at the entrance of Tamarack Nature Center. Here you can clearly hear the higher-pitched, melodic trill of the Gray treefrog. Listen for another call that sounds similar, but is faster and lower pitched. That’s the Cope’s gray treefrog. American toads come in around 15 seconds with their sustained trill. Boreal chorus frogs are clear and easy to distinguish in this recording.
Tamarack Nature Center
Tamarack Lake is interesting because it has a large vegetated buffer but is still impaired for nutrients. All 8 frog and toad species were detected here. A variety of mammals are also found in this park.
Ermine show their seasonal color variation (brown in the summer and white in the winter) in wetlands adjacent to Tamarack Lake.
Muskrats are especially busy in late fall, preparing their lodge for winter. This pair of muskrats was busy working together, making the perfect place to spend the winter months.
Birds are also photographed at remote-camera sites, like this Pileated woodpecker. We feature highlights of birds; other techniques are better than cameras for sampling bird diversity.
Tamarack Nature Center is a fairly small protected area at 320 acres. It has a high amount of roads and development surrounding it. Invasive species and nutrient inputs to the lakes reduced habitat quality for many species in the past. Prairie restoration has been successful, and new restoration efforts are underway to remove invasive plants like buckthorn and Reed canary grass. VLAWMO is working with Ramsey County Soil and Water Conservation Division to restore Teal Pond. Visit Tamarack Nature Center to see these projects as habitat quality improves.
"Humans merely share the earth." -Chief Seattle
VLAWMO conducted frog and toad surveys in 2019-2020. We conducted 2 years of surveys to build solid baseline data. We will use these baseline data to learn more about our projects and resulting environmental improvements in the watershed over time.