NEPA GIS DAY 2021

Topic: Walkability and Place making- A Case Study of Braeton Parkway and Environs, Portmore St. Catherine.

Greater Portmore Master Plan

Maxar | NEPA
Powered by Esri

Introduction

Researches have shown that most streets in the core urban centers of the world are car centric (USEPA, 2019). This makes it difficult for people to use the most basic form of transport which is walking, bicycling and other human powered modes for their day to day activities like to commute to work, to stay socially connected, and for daily exercises. This has contributed to the decline in physical and psychological health leading to a rise in obesity rates, high rate of usage of fossil fuel, higher transportation costs, traffic congestion and continued environmental degradation. For most places, car-centric approaches to land-use and transportation planning has led to sprawl and disconnected communities (Zhang & Mu, 2019). To counter these effects, attention is now turning to fixing existing built environments and rethinking how to plan and design new communities. For example the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has stated that carbon emissions must be cut by 45% by 2030 compared with pre-industrial levels (IPCC 2018). Also, during Conference of Party (COP 26) in Glasgow, countries, cities, carmakers stated their commitment to end fossil-fuel vehicles by 2040. Walkability has taken centre stage in the debate over "net zero emission". In broad terms, walkability is defined by the quality of which the built environment enables the mobility of pedestrians. Pedestrians traditionally are defined as the individuals traveling by foot, but it has recently been expanded to include those who use wheelchairs or other assistive devices/means like bicycles. walking and bicycling are known as ‘green’ type of transportation (Lo, 2009). Apart from its ability to reduce traffic, it has low level of environmental impact and has both social and recreational importance. Planning towards achieving zero emission requires design that promotes walkability.

Place-making on the other hand, involves creating comfortable meeting points and destinations in a community. But, even if there are places to visit within a short walk persons are unlikely to walk if the way to get there was unsafe or unpleasant. Certain features in the built environment inhibit walkability and the lack of such features can influence peoples perceptions and decisions to walk to and from destinations.

Features of walkability and place making

Research Question

The main question to be answered in this study is: 

What is the existing condition of the Braeton Parkway streetscape? Can it support place making and walkability?

Research Objectives

Objectives of this study was to:

  1. Show advanced GIS tools/application available for planning and environmental management.
  2. Assess the existing streetscape in the study area
  3. Create a GIS-based 3D model using ESRI City Engine to communicate how the proposed streetscape of the study area should look like.

Geo Design using GIS

Geo design is concerned with shaping the physical environment. It helps to address the complexity of form and function of cities. Technologies used in Geo design can provide real time analytics and feedback allowing for metric and reporting output that aide in decision making. In most situations it is difficult for members of the public to understand complex drawings or city plans presented to them but using 3D to present such information is a win-win situation.

Study Area

Braeton Parkway and Environs, Portmore (Sun City) St Catherine.

Population Growth

Between 2001 and 2011 St. Catherine was the fastest growing parish growing by 7 per cent at an annual rate of 0.72 per cent, doubling the national rate of 0.36 per cent(STATIN 2011). 

Population Trend.

Urban Development in Portmore

Braeton Parkway Case Study

The Braeton Parkway (Twenty Route) represented with purple on the map is presently one of the busiest roads in Portmore due to the high commercial activities happening in the area. There has been rising commercial development along this road. This corridor host the following reputable companies/organizations:

  1. IBEX (BPO)
  2. Hilo supermarket
  3. Total Gas Station with its first Automatic Car Wash in Jamaica.
  4. Singer company
  5. Scotia Bank
  6. First Global Bank
  7. Sovereign Village(Popeyes, Monarch Pharmacy, Dominos, Wendys, Subway and progressive supermarket)
  8. Department of Inland Revenue(Tax Office)
  9. Proposed Portmore PriceMart
  10. Sagicor Bank
  11. Island Grill
  12. First Caribbean Bank
  13. Superlative Auto
  14. 100 Man Police Station
  15. Portmore Municipal Corporation
  16. Sunshine Outlet Mall
  17. Sunshine Palace Cinema

Methodology for the Study

This study employed participatory observation, Google street view and photography techniques to assess the existing condition of Braeton Parkway and its environs. The quality of the street furniture/facilities were examined, particularly taking note of the attributes of the sidewalks and other street facilities. Finally streetscape and ecological areas were superimposed on the existing landscape.

Presentation of Data

Observations during data collection:

  • Traffic congestion on the Braeton Parkway (Twenty Route) at all times of the day.
  • There are no curbside in most sections of the road
  •  The roads are not user friendly with poles at the middle of the pedestrian walkway
  • Sunshine intensity and heat
  • Taxis picking up passengers along the road thereby causing traffic congestion
  • Illegal vending along this route causing traffic obstruction
  • No adequate signage/rules on the road
  •  No uniform setback this makes the streets not user friendly
  • There are no ramps for the physically challenged

    

Maxar | NEPA
Powered by Esri

      Existing Conditions

      Braeton Parkway

            Braeton Parkway: Traffic Light by Total Gas Station

            Gully Near the proposed Portmore Pricemart

            Braeton Hill Existing Walkability

            Some Portmore residents currently walk as a form of exercise Braeton Hill is one of those popular destination in Portmore.

            Creating the 3D Model in City Engine Project

            3D Design - ProposedStreetscape/Furniture

            Streetscape Is a term used to describe the natural and built fabric of the street, and defined as the design quality of the street and its visual effect, particularly how the paved area is laid out and treated. It includes buildings, the street surface, and also the fixtures and fittings that facilitate its use – from bus shelters and signage to planting schemes’’ [Rehan 2013]. 

            Elements of Streetscape:

            Streetscaping can include changes to the road cross section, traffic management, sidewalk conditions, landscaping (mainly tree cover), street furniture (utility poles, benches, garbage cans, etc.), building fronts, and materials specifications. It also encompasses improving signage. 

            Place-Making

            Places of interest

            Improved Urban Mass Transit using trams and Electric powered Buses.

            Electric Powered Trams and Trains

            Parks and Green Areas

            Improved Security and safety

            More Green Spaces and Recreational Areas

            View of Braeton Hills

            Improve Braeton Hill

            Create Kids Play Areas

            Green Spaces and Parks/Emergency Services

            Emergency Services

            3D Web Scene Link

            Recommendations

            Achieving such high level infrastructural upgrade will require a lot of finance. This will require international partnerships, private/public partnership including maintenance agreement plans . It is therefore recommended that the following sponsorship and maintenance procedures be considered:

            • Seek grants from private entities to develop transport infrastructure

            Seek grants from private developers who may volunteer or maybe willing to finance, install or maintain streetscape improvement.

            • Partnership between the public and private sector

            Enable good partnership between the government and Private sector firms particularly with firms whose Corporate Social Responsibilities are to invest in community or city based infrastructure . Such partnerships may be allowed between the private sector corporations and the municipality/government entity to fund and maintain streetscape projects.

            • Encourage Grassroots Partnership

            Community residents, business owners, or other parties may be encouraged to organise themselves to invest in transport facilities.

            • Special Areas

            Allow certain communities or areas to invest in streetscape or green spaces within their jurisdiction fees for usage of such areas maybe imposed to use such facilities so that such infrastructures can be maintained . Private lands can be used for such spaces as well. The owners of such lands can be compensated or granted certain incentives.

            Green Climate Fund

            Low carbon transport programmes account for a growing share of the mitigation finance provided through existing climate funds. Government should identify such finance. Transport contributes a significant share of global CO2 emissions, with trends predicting a twofold increase by 2030. Growth in emissions will accelerate with increasing demands for travel. Transport will have a distinct impact on future emissions, and there is an urgent need to encourage compact, connected urban forms linked by sustainable transit solutions, instead of sprawling, car-dominated and high-emission development. The use of private cars might grow fast in some countries, while others are dominated by two-wheelers. Some countries have introduced more sustainable transport systems such as Bus Rapid Transports (BRT), but there remains a need to scale up their reach, coverage and functionality.

            References

            • Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) (2018) IPCC Special Report on Global Warming of 1.5°C Accessed from https://www.ipcc.ch/2018/10/08/summary-for-policymakers-of-ipcc-special-report-on-global-warming-of-1-5c-approved-by-governments/ on November 12 2021,
            • Lo, R. H. (2009). Walkability: what Is it?. J. Urbanism: Int. Res. Placemaking Urban Sustainability 2, 145–166. doi:10.1080/17549170903092867

              • Reeman M Rehan,( 2013) "Sustainable streetscape as an effective tool in sustainable urban design," HBRC, pp. 173-186,
            • United States Environmental Protection Agency. (2019). Smog, Soot, and Other Air Pollution from Transportation. Retrieved from Environmental Protection Agency: https://www.epa.gov/transportation-air-pollution-and-climate-change/smog-soot-andlocal-air-pollution on November 11 2021
            • Zhang, X., & Mu, L. (2019). The perceived importance and objective measurement of walkability in the built environment rating. Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science, 0(0), 1-17. doi:10.1177/23998083|9832305

            Features of walkability and place making

            Population Trend.

            Braeton Parkway

            Braeton Parkway: Traffic Light by Total Gas Station

            Gully Near the proposed Portmore Pricemart

            Places of interest

            View of Braeton Hills

            Improve Braeton Hill