Earthquake Vulnerability in San Francisco, CA

Assessing which SF neighborhoods are in need of additional support against seismic hazards with GIS

Background

The United States ranks #4 in the world as the country with the most earthquakes. According to the  USGS , Alaska has the most earthquakes per year, but California has the most earthquakes that cause damage in the United States. Thousands of earthquakes occur in the state each year, mostly concentrated mostly in the Bay Area and Los Angeles regions, some of the most populated areas.

The United States has thousands of fault lines running through the entire country. Almost 1,000 fault lines in the United States have been active in the last 1.6 million years.

100 of these fault lines are in California.

Hundreds of fault lines run all over the state, making California well-known around the world as an earthquake hotspot. Currently, the state has about  200 potentially dangerous fault lines and over 70% of the population lives within 30 miles of a fault line .

Major fault lines near San Francisco:

  • San Andreas
  • Hayward
  • San Gergorio
  • Mount Diablo
  • Greenville
  • Calaveras

Major Bay Area Earthquakes

June 1, 1838

San Andreas, magnitude 7, San Andreas fault

October 21, 1868

Hayward, magnitude 7, Hayward fault

April 18, 1906

San Francisco, magnitude 7.9, San Andreas fault

Loma Prieta Earthquake, 1989

October 17, 1989

Loma Preita, magnitude 6.9, San Andreas fault

2014–2043

The Big One, ?

The San Andreas and Hayward faults are the largest and closest fault lines to San Francisco.

Stretching over 800 miles, the San Andreas Fault is the longest fault line in California.

The Hayward Fault is notoriously known as the  "most dangerous fault in America"  because it runs through densely populated cities such as Richmond, El Cerrito, Berkeley, Oakland, and San Leandro.

"72% probability of one or more M ≥ 6.7 earthquakes from 2014 to 2043 in the San Francisco Bay Region." –USGS

  • 51% probability magnitude 7 earthquake
  • 20% probability magnitude 7.5 earthquake

25 mile buffers around each fault.


What makes an earthquake dangerous?

  • Magnitude – earthquakes usually begin causing damage when they get to a magnitude of  4 or 5 . The next major earthquake to hit San Francisco is likely to surpass this at 6.7 or greater.
  • Location – areas closer to a fault line experience earthquakes the most intensely as they are closer to the source. San Francisco is within 25 miles of two major fault lines, the Hayward Fault and the San Andreas Fault.
  • Population – a higher population density area means that there is a higher chance of more people getting hurt in a disaster. San Francisco has a population of 873,965 occupying just under 50 square miles of land, according to the  2020 and 2010 censuses .
  • Infrastructure– earthquakes are most fatal when people are in or surrounded by unsafe buildings. Despite efforts to safeguard the city, San Francisco still has almost 5,000 soft-story buildings that need to be updated.

View of the Sunset District


GIS Analysis

Which parts of San Francisco are the most vulnerable to a major earthquake?

San Francisco has 41 neighborhoods.

Seismic hazard zones are determined by liquefaction and landslide risk.

San Francisco currently has approximately 4,941 soft story properties.

"Earthquakes don't kill people, buildings do."

The  San Francisco Department of Building Inspection  has determined that soft story buildings are unstable and unsafe in earthquakes because of their weak first-floor frames. The Mandatory Soft Story Retrofit Program pushes property owners to update their buildings accordingly and updates the status of soft story buildings every week.

In 2016, the  U.S. Census  categorized economically distressed areas (EDAs) in San Francisco based on the population densities and median household incomes of different block groups in the city.

The highest population density (>100,000 people per square mile) areas are in northeast San Francisco.

These block groups also have some of the lowest median household incomes (MHI) (< $55,000 per year).

They are generally in the Tenderloin and Chinatown neighborhoods.


Results

The greater Bay Area faces high earthquake risk. Fortunately, no single location in San Francisco is not at the highest risk based on all of these variables. Instead, there are multiple combinations of factors to consider that places different neighborhoods at a higher risk. This means that safeguarding these areas that are likely to be severely affected are location-dependent because they are at risk of different things in an earthquake.

Greatest number of soft-story properties + in seismic hazard zone = Marina District

High population density + in seismic hazard zone = Tenderloin and Chinatown neighborhoods

EDA + in seismic hazard zone = Tenderloin and Chinatown neighborhoods

High population density + greatest number of soft-story properties = Nob Hill neighborhood

Greatest number of soft-story properties nearby + MHI < $55,000 per year = Western Addition neighborhood

EDA + greatest number of soft-story properties nearby = Nob Hill neighborhood

View of the Sunset District