
Team I10 Solution: Extended Bike Lanes
MacChangers 2022-2023 Final Deliverable - Team I10
Executive Summary
Group Members
Built Environment and Infrastructure I10
Mission Statement
"Human centered design is important to our team because any design that does not meet the needs of the end user is not helpful to the end user. We want to develop a design that not only solves our chosen problem, but does so in a way that appeals to the end users."
Our How Might We Question
How might we increase the safety and accessibility of biking in and around the McMaster campus?
Human Centred Design
Our Research Findings
SDG Alignment
SDG 3: Good Health and Well-Being
Target 3.4: By 2030, reduce by one third premature mortality from non-communicable diseases through prevention and treatment and promote mental health and well-being
Rationale: Various research studies show that biking improves one's mental health. Therefore, creating a conducive biking environment that encourages biking to campus would help reduce deaths caused by mental illnesses like depression and has been shown to make people generally feel happier.
Target 3.6: By 2020, halve the number of global deaths and injuries from road traffic accidents
Rationale: Creating a safe and conducive environment for bikers and other road users on campus would reduce the number of accidental collisions between road users which cause injuries and property damage.
SDG 9: Industry Innovation and Infrastructure
Target 9.1: Develop quality, reliable, sustainable and resilient infrastructure, including regional and trans-border infrastructure, to support economic development and human well-being, with a focus on affordable and equitable access for all.
Rationale: This goal aligns with our problem statement as we aim to improve the safety and accessibility of biking around McMaster campus, thus developing a reliable and sustainable infrastructure for our stakeholders. We can address this target by creating separate paths for bikers, which can promote more students and staff members to consider it as their primary mode of transportation.
SDG 11: Sustainable Cities and Communities
Target 11.2: By 2030, provide access to safe, affordable, accessible and sustainable transport systems for all, improving road safety, notably by expanding public transport, with special attention to the needs of those in vulnerable situations, women, children, persons with disabilities and older persons.
Rationale: Creating a safe, accessible biking environment is the central goal of our HMWQ. An organized biking system would benefit the campus and its surrounding areas with enhanced road safety. It would potentially increase the efficiency of public transportation on campus and provide a safer space for vulnerable individuals.
Case Studies and Findings
Revised Questions After Research
Summary of Meetings with Community Members:
1st Meeting Notes:
Traffic Measures:
Stop signs are only used by vehicles. When traffic mixing is allowed, people drive slower.
Not many traffic common measures on campus for bikers.
Only priority to pedestrians given over drivers.
It is hard to figure out people affected by the lack of bike incentives.
McMaster focuses on the measure if it is a current need and tries to solve it.
Forsyth Avenue and Sterling Street are the busiest and are a big focus point for risk.
Bike Storage Facilities:
Kenneth Taylor Hall has a bike storage facility to store bikes that requires paying.
Not ideal because it's stored outside without a roof.
Bikes stolen off campus occur quite frequently.
Collisions On Campus:
Not too much on collisions on campus but look into work done on collisions that have occurred and who’s been involved.
Ask current McMaster Master’s students doing research in transportation.
Chat with other Mac Changers group members about what would encourage more people to:
Bike on campus.
Having free bike parking places provided by the city.
Initiatives that encourage more people to bike.
Incentives for bikers:
- Ploughing bike lanes in the winter is done in the city of Hamilton.
- Look into what Calgary is in extreme weather conditions and the incentives they have for people riding bikes in cold weather.
- Look into how to inform students of how to prepare for biking in poor conditions.
- Research BikeBuddy and MacCycle in McMaster and learn about how to bike on campus and repair their bike but it was shut down due to lack of funding.
- Look into what went wrong with previous initiatives and what could be done for more sustainability.
- Look into the Hamilton bike share referendum investigation (about 5 years ago).
2nd Meeting Notes:
Safety Measure:
McMaster has priority zones and pedestrian lanes.
Painted bike lanes are present but no physical infrastructure, separate pathways along Cootes Drive in Hamilton.
Things that are not bike specific are implemented, curb extensions, speed limits, speed bumps, dedicated bus lanes, just some examples.
Usually there exists a campus master plan so look into that.
Not just having a single bike lane but making sure it's connected so it could be more consistent.
Sharrows are painted on the road, causing more collisions from shared road space.
Rideshare
Rideshare asks questions to members in surveys, but the information and data can help show what cycling infrastructure people need.
Using the heat map which shows where people are riding bikes across campus, we can get a picture of the areas around campus with the most activity.
Rideshare does not change wheels, winter bike tires are not necessary as bare pavement wears down on them too much, it is often clear enough to ride on.
Rideshare promotes more people cycling in different weather conditions
Bikers shift to bikeshare in winter to make things easier.
Making sure infrastructure is maintained and cleared in winter brings up usage of biking.
Bike share bike lock conditions are maintained in winter (It is not a problem because internal mechanisms are not affected).
Common Collision Areas:
- The driveways and exits to parking lots, cars aren’t looking for bikes on the sidewalk or going at that speed, in some scenarios it becomes more dangerous.
- Bike lane crossing with turning lane shared with cars, drivers might not expect someone to come that quickly.
- Cyclists coming by parked cars are hit by opening doors.
Our Scoped Problem Definition:
"We were concerned for the safety of bikers as they are the most vulnerable road users. We wanted to make the roads safer for bikers while avoiding obstruction of traffic and maintaining pedestrian safety. Hence, we aim to improve traffic flow at intersections using new infrastructures or processes to prioritise biker’s safety on McMaster campus. We want our solution to be cost-effective, easy to implement and adapt, and energy efficient. Our solution must not obstruct traffic flow, disobey municipal traffic laws, or significantly affect surrounding greenspace."
Our Solution Ideas
Pedestrian & Cyclist Crossing Light
Children's Hospital Intersection Traffic Light
Biking Lanes
Equitable and Inclusive Considerations
Considerations made about our solutions to make them more equitable and inclusive while exploring the 4 lenses of accessibility; Physical, Communicative, Financial, and Digital.
Project Viability
Considerations made about our solutions to determine their viability, from a financial, social and environmental perspective.
Final Solution
Our final solution prototype.