![](https://cdn.arcgis.com/sharing/rest/content/items/9c0b53e548624e3f80a050480e1d9f8d/resources/MKMRMnnE4ohEEuSZQ17nU.jpg?w=20)
Commercial Fishing in the Atlantic Ocean
How Overfishing Led to the Collapse of the Atlantic Cod Fishery off the Coast of Canada
Introduction
How has overfishing of Atlantic cod impacted the ecological, economic, and social systems, and what lessons can be learned to promote sustainable fishing practices? The Atlantic cod fishery has been one of the most historically significant marine industries, both as a crucial source of food and economic livelihood for coastal communities in the North Atlantic, especially in countries like Canada and the United States. However, overfishing of cod has led to the dramatic collapse of this once-abundant fishery, particularly in the waters off Newfoundland and Labrador in Canada. The cod population, which once supported a thriving fishing industry, now faces the risk of extinction or significant depletion.
Cod fishers working in a thriving fishing industry 1952
The collapse of the Atlantic cod fishery holds wide-ranging implications for environmental, economic, and social systems. Ecologically, the depletion of cod has caused cascading effects on marine ecosystems, altering food webs and threatening species that depend on cod as a key prey species. Economically, the collapse has devastated fishing industries and local economies, leading to loss of livelihoods for thousands of fishermen and related industries, such as fish processing. Socially, the decline in cod populations has sparked debates over the sustainability of fishing practices, the role of government regulation, and the tension between economic development and environmental conservation.
Literature Review
One of the key factors contributing to the collapse of the Atlantic cod fishery was the failure of formal institutions to manage the resource effectively. The Canadian government’s Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO) and international bodies like the Northwest Atlantic Fisheries Organization (NAFO) established regulations to control cod fishing, such as quotas and seasonal restrictions. However, these regulations were often too lenient or poorly enforced, which allowed overfishing to continue unchecked. The tragedy of the commons is evident here, where individual fishermen, acting in their self-interest, overexploited the resource, knowing that the consequences of depletion would be shared by the broader community. In response to the collapse, the Canadian government eventually imposed a moratorium on cod fishing in 1992, which remains in place to this day. This drastic measure, while necessary to prevent total depletion, led to significant socio-economic consequences, particularly for fishing communities that were heavily dependent on cod fishing for their livelihoods. This policy failure underscores the importance of adaptive governance, where institutions need to be flexible and responsive to ecological changes, and should involve active monitoring and adjustment of regulations over time.
Cod Populations off the coast of Canada in 1850
The Atlantic cod population, particularly off the coast of Newfoundland and Labrador, experienced a dramatic collapse during the late 20th century, primarily due to overfishing. For centuries, Atlantic cod was a vital resource for coastal communities in the North Atlantic, especially in Newfoundland, where it supported both local economies and the broader maritime trade network. By the early 20th century, however, industrial-scale fishing had ramped up, significantly increasing pressure on cod populations. Advances in fishing technology, such as trawl nets, larger vessels, and improved processing techniques, made it easier for fleets to catch large quantities of cod. By the 1950s and 1960s, overfishing began to deplete the cod stock, though the full extent was not immediately recognized.
Significantly reduced cod populations off the coast of Canada in 2005
During the 1970s and 1980s, fishing fleets continued to operate at an unsustainable rate and by the 1980s, cod stocks began to decline significantly. Scientific assessments indicated that the spawning biomass (the total mass of fish capable of reproduction) was falling rapidly, but these warnings were largely ignored or dismissed due to the significant economic pressures from the fishing industry. Overfishing not only reduced the number of cod, but it also led to a decrease in their size. Cod that once reached maturity at around 80 centimeters now reproduce at younger ages due to the pressure of increased fishing, with the average size at maturity dropping to about 65 centimeters. The size of the fish matters because larger, older cod tend to spawn more frequently, contributing to more productive and resilient populations.
Biologists were concerned that this shift in size and age could indicate a permanent evolutionary change in the population, making it even more difficult to restore cod numbers. While lab experiments support this idea, studies of wild populations—which have focused on only a few genetic markers—have yet to provide definitive conclusions.
Case Study Analysis
Traditional cod fishers in the early 1900s
In the 1970s, Tony, the son of an immigrant fisherman, worked on his father’s boat off Georges Bank, where cod were so abundant that nets would often tip the boat, with fish piled high on the deck. Tony earned up to $100,000 in just two months of summer work, making school seem unnecessary. The cod fishery was central to New England’s economy and culture, with Cape Cod named for the abundance of cod, which fueled the region's development.
However, by the 1990s, cod populations had collapsed due to overfishing. The cod population in the Gulf of Maine is now reduced to less than 1% of its former size. As fishing technology advanced, factory trawlers equipped with GPS and sonar vacuumed up cod at unsustainable rates, despite warnings from scientists. The Newfoundland fishery collapsed in the 1990s, and the New England Fisheries Management Council was slow to respond to the crisis. In the end the federal government intervened and put a stop to all cod fishing in 1992 that lasted until 1994 resulting in the loss of over 45,000 jobs nationwide.
Modern cod fishers working on a commercial fishing vessel in Canada
Tony’s father, Francesco, came to America in the early 1900s, when cod were plentiful. Tony inherited the family boat, “The Frankie C,” but fishing soon became unprofitable as the cod stocks dwindled. Government regulations limiting fishing further impacted the business, and Tony eventually sold the boat and moved away just like so many others impacted by the species on the brink of extinction and government sanctions. He later opened a fish and chips shop on the west coast, but after struggling with depression from having to completely remake hie life, he died from a heroin overdose.
Conclusion
The result of cod fishing in the Atlantic has been the severe depletion of cod populations, particularly in the Gulf of Maine and off the coast of Newfoundland. Overfishing, driven by technological advancements like factory trawlers and GPS-assisted sonar, led to the collapse of cod stocks by the 1990s. Cod populations have been reduced to as little as 1% of their former size, with limited signs of recovery despite fishing bans and conservation efforts.
Institutional policies, such as the 1992 moratorium on cod fishing in Canada and fishing restrictions imposed by the U.S. government, aimed to protect cod stocks and allow for recovery. However, these policies were often slow to implement and were met with resistance from the fishing industry. As a result, the slow action by the government let fishermen decimate the fish populations thereby forcing the government to implement a full shutdown costing many people their jobs. The situation exemplifies the challenges of managing shared natural resources and balancing economic interests with environmental sustainability.