
Lake Erie Microplastics, July 2020
This story map takes an interactive look at Lake Erie and its watershed using data that I collected in July of 2020
First... What are microplastics?
Microplastics are small pieces or fragments of plastic debris. Microplastics come from a wide array of sources - namely industrial waste, wastewater discharge from laundry, and other products.
Microplastics strands circled in red
Something as simple as washing a pair of socks can introduce microplastics into the watershed. Loose plastic fibers (polyester, nylon, acrylic, etc) leave the clothing, and enter the watershed through wastewater discharge. Microplastics uptake then occurs for everything in the ecosystem. The small strands enter the ecosystem after mixing into the water plants and animals drink, absorption into the root caps of plants, and biomagnification from aquatic species. There, the plastics will remain for an estimated 400+ years. However, the breakdown of microplastics often causes them to split and fragment into smaller pieces, creating even smaller microplastics that have an easier time entering the ecosystem. [1]
Cloud cover on the two sample collection days - July 13th on the left and July 16th on the right. Weather on July 13th was mostly sunny, July 16th had some morning showers and was cloudy for the rest of the day. (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration)
Looking Closer
Lake Erie itself is 25,700 km² in area, with a volume of 484 km³. The total area of the Lake Erie + Lake St. Clair drainage system is 78,000km², with more than 12 million inhabitants calling the watershed home between the United States and Canada. [2]
Below is an interactive map of the watershed. Take a look at various rivers, streams, cities, farms, and forests that call Lake Erie home.
Map of Land Cover with cities, state borders, and rivers within in the (American) Lake Erie watershed.
Data Collection Trip
A map of the planned sample points made in Google Maps back in June 2020 (Google Maps)
The trip would be about 1,250 km (760 mi) in total, covering 40 points along the entire American coast of Lake Erie that appeared to be accessible. Grant funding secured through the Maine Space Grant Consortium covered the expenses and supplies necessary. In the days leading up to the trip, routes were planned, spreadsheets created, and supplies were gathered. Below is a photo map tour of the trip!
01 / 24
1
Road Trip Dinner
Eager to begin the sampling, and not wanting to drive to suburban Detroit, MI at 4 AM on a Monday morning, I left on July 12th and spent the night outside of Toledo, OH.
2
First Sample!
Our first sample was collected in Gibraltar, MI at the beginning of Lake Erie. Canada can be seen across the lake!
3
First Sample!
After filling a bottle of water, the pH was measured and recorded. Unfortunately, that data was lost due to data corruption in the process of switching computers over the summer.
4
Inflatable Slurpee
A very tempting offer that early in the morning with such a long drive ahead.
5
Industry along western Lake Erie
Just outside of Sandusky, OH.
6
Lakeview Park, Lorain, OH
Busy day at the local beach on a nice and clear summer afternoon.
7
Lorain Lighthouse
Commonly photographed and painted lighthouse in Lake Erie, in Lorain, OH.
8
Approaching Cleveland, OH
Approaching Cleveland, OH on a hazy summer afternoon.
9
Banned from New York?
New York added residents of Ohio to its quarantine requirements on July 14th... and I was planning on driving to New York that night. With the trip in jeopardy, I was able to confirm that since the mission was (mainly) to collect scientific data, it would fall under a medium-term travel (<36h that requires overnight stay).
10
Cuyahoga River (The Burning River)
One of the largest subwatersheds by population and a considerable industry, I expected that this sample would contain many microplastics. However, for a river that repeatedly caught on fire, the area is now restored quite nicely.
11
New York State Line
New York State required that this form be filled out prior to arrival.
12
Late Night Arrival
In order to comply with the quarantine requirements for New York, we could not enter the state until late, arriving in Buffalo around 1 AM on July 15th.
13
Peace Bridge
Could have taken a late night detour to Canada had the border been open!
14
Niagara Falls
No trip to the Buffalo area is complete without seeing Niagara Falls. The Niagara River was also part of our sample collection anyway, as all of Lake Erie ultimately flows through the river and these falls. The close falls is American Falls, and the farther one is Horseshoe Falls. Across the river is Niagara Falls, Ontario, Canada.
15
Niagara Falls
16
Niagara Falls
17
Buffalo, NY Skyline
An early morning photo of the skyline of Buffalo about 21 km from downtown in Hamburg, NY.
18
Evangola State Park, NY
A couple of sand dunes impeded the path to the sample site.
19
Silver Creek, NY
According the historical placard near the bridge, this "skew arch" was the second bridge of its type in the world when built in 1869.
20
Steamship Erie
21
Ripley Beach, NY
The erosion here took out access to the water. Still determined to collect the water, my friend scaled down the crumbling shale. The water here was exceptionally clear and beautiful (however photos did not show this because it was lightly raining).
22
Ripley Beach, NY
The path down.
23
Ripley Beach, NY
24
Erosion in Geneva, OH
Lake Erie experienced record high water levels in 2020. At one point, the beach was eroding at about 1 meter per day!
Sample Analysis
With the samples collected, the next step of a microplastics analysis is to filter the samples. This involves weighing the samples for volume (1g H₂O= 1mL H₂O), and then filtering through a 47mm filter with 0.45 µm (0.00045 mm) pore size.
Filtering the samples and their appearance post-filtration
After, Fenton's reagent is created by heating (for each sample) 2 mL FeSO₄ + 20 mL of 0.1 M HCl to 75°C. 5 mL 30% H₂O₂ is added to the heated solution, which is then added to the flask containing each filter. Each flask is then covered with parafilm, and left for a few days to oxidize and break down most organic material. This primarily leaves just rocks, sand, glass, and microplastics behind.
Creating Fenton's reagent and the samples oxidizing
Once oxidation is complete, the samples are filtered again with a new 47mm filter with a 0.45 µm pore size. After spending a few days in the Fenton's reagent, the old filters are too brittle to be used again. The samples are then counted for microplastics using a microscope between 10-12x magnification. This count is then divided by the volume of each sample, giving the final comparable measurement of microplastics particles per liter.
Some of the samples under the microscope. The far left sample also includes bits of glass, likely originating from a former glass factory near Ashtabula, OH. All samples directly along the lake east of Ashtabula, OH contained tiny pieces of glass similar to the ones pictured above.
Exploring The Results
The samples yielded an average of 46.5 ± 23.93 microplastics particles per liter.
Sample Collection Points Map. Clicking each point loads a popup containing data from each sample.
Looking at the above map, the microplastics concentration appears to increase closer to larger population centers and in areas with larger industries. The cluster east of Ashtabula, OH may be related to the industrial activities in the area. Further statistical analysis is needed to determine if relationships between population and industrial activity exist.
In the below map, watersheds are created from the sample points. There does not seem to be a strong relationship between the area of the watershed and the amount of microplastics found in the samples. However, looking at the land cover of each watershed, it is observed that microplastics originated more from areas with a higher density (population and industry) than more agricultural or forested areas.
Sample Collection Points Map with Land Cover