Visualizing Sustainable Transportation Choices for K-12
What is the average carbon footprint via transportation for LA county?
According to the University of California Berkeley, for each household in Los Angeles (LA) county contributes an average of 14.3 total Carbon (CO2) emissions per year (tCO2e/yr) in transportation.
The total household Carbon footprint in LA county is measured at 42.7 tCO2e/yr and the total Carbon footprint for the county is measured at 139,626,359 tCO2e/yr.
With 3,257,476 houses recorded in LA county, this means that out of 139,626,359 tCO2e/yr about 46,724,907 tCO2e/yr is contributed from transportation.
Transportation Footprint
According to the Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, transportation is the largest source of carbon emission in the U.S.
To reduce GHG (greenhouse gas) emissions, commuters/transporters can use cleaner modes of transportation.
Importance of teaching K-12 on sustainable choices
With transportation being the largest contributor to carbon emissions in the U.S., this is a great topic to bring awareness on more sustainable options on student's ways to school. Geographic Information Systems (GIS) can be a great tool to introduce those sustainable options by student's mapping their routes and measuring their transportation carbon footprint. Not only will this benefit their perspective on sustainability, but introduce them to new skills from GIS.
'
Average Commute time in LA County
In 2018, the average commute time in LA county is about 30 minutes.
According to Data USA for LA County, LA employees have a longer commute time than the normal US worker, which is an average of 25.7 minutes and 4.16% of LA workers have a super commute that can be over 90 minutes.
How does transportation choices impact our carbon footprint?
Gasoline-powered Vehicles
- Gasoline vehicles relies heavily on petroleum which contributes half of the CO2 emissions in the U.S.
- Using one gallon of gas contributes 20 pounds of CO2. This means that the average vehicle in the U.S. emits 6-9 tons on CO2 each year.
Hybrid vehicles
- Hybrid vehicles relies on petroleum and electricity.
- 50% less emissions are emitted from a hybrid vehicle when comparing to a gasoline vehicle.
Electric Vehicles (EVs)
- EVs relies on an electric motor which is powered by energy from rechargeable batteries and provide a low-carbon alternative to gasoline vehicles.
- EVs vehicles emit no exhaust which has a zero impact on your carbon footprint.
Public Transportation
- Households in the U.S. that live near a bus or rail line contribute the least amount of carbon emissions. An average of 4,400 driving miles are reduced for these households.
- According to the Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, "communities with strong public transportation can reduce the nation's carbon emission by 37 million metric tons yearly".
Active Transportation
- Bicycling and walking relies on your energy!
- Choosing active transportation reduces your carbon footprint, traffic congestion, demand for oil, and environmental impact with less destruction on natural lands.
This map displays all routes including public transportation, active transportation, and highways & roads.
What if High School Students could learn about both GIS and more sustainable commute methods to school?
The purpose of this Story Map is to showcase an activity on how educators can teach the topic of sustainable transportation while introducing geospatial technology.
Benefits of introducing spatial thinking in K-12 education
According to Esri, "Children learn in a variety of ways, but visual learning is especially effective. Using maps in the classroom illustrates geographic context, helping students connect lessons with real places."
GIS enhances STEM learning
Science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) education is a multidisciplinary approach that can improve education and the workforce, and enforces national competitiveness.
GIS allows students to become spatial thinkers with collecting, analyzing, and visualizing their data. Spatial technology can be used for student to engage in STEM curriculum and prepare them as STEM professionals.
Study Site:
Los Angeles Trade Technical College (LATTC)
- LATTC has a Bridge to College program that allows K-12 students concurrently enroll in college courses while still being enrolled in high school. Since K-12 students are able to attend LATTC, the campus is used as the study site for the activity.
The map shows, a 5 mile radius from LATTC to display all public transportation options and bike lanes.
GIS activity on sustainable ways to commute to school
Different modes of transportation, their distance, travel time, emitted CO2 in lb of CO2-e will be evaluated. Modes of transportation will include commuter vehicles, public transit, and active transportation that include bicycling & walking. Commuter vehicles will compare a gasoline-powered vehicle, hybrid vehicle, and all electric vehicle.
Routes were chosen based off distance. There will be 4 examples of routes displayed. First, a student commuting into school from a residential area in LA county. A student commuting on public transit from a coastal location in LA county. A student who lives in Los Angeles city and bikes to school. Lastly, a student who also lives in Los Angeles city and walks to school.
Data used to measure transportation time, distance, and CO2 footprint is obtained from Map My Emissions Website . Routes were created in ArcMap, by creating a File Geodatabase and creating a Feature Class then using Editor.
Commuter Vehicles
This route is mapped for a student commuting into school from a residential area in LA county.
Since this student is commuting from a further distance they were given a commuter vehicle as their mode of transportation. Depending on what type of commuter vehicle they own, we can observe the difference in pound of carbon emissions (CO^2-e) they have contributed.
- Gasoline-powered vehicle – distance: 22.55 miles, duration 33 mins, and emissions: 15.91 lb of CO^2-e
- Gasoline-hybrid – distance: 22.55, 33 mins, and emissions: 10.44 lb of CO^2-e
- All electric – distance: 22.55 miles, duration: 33 mins, and emissions: 0.23 lb of CO^2-e
Public Transportation
This route is mapped for a student commuting from a coastal location within LA County.
The commute distance is not much of a difference from the vehicle example, although this student was given a public transportation as their way of transporting to school. For this route, bus and rail were used with walking intermissions to change mode of transportation.
- Distance: 20.65 miles
- Duration: 1 hour and 18 minutes
- Emissions: 7.14 lb of CO2-e
Active Transportation
These routes include a bicycle route and a walk route. Both the bicycle and walk route is mapped for a student that is located within Los Angeles City.
A student's carbon footprint when cycling or walking is lessened due to their choice of transportation emitting no carbon.
Bicycle route
- Distance: 3.85 miles
- Duration: 1 hour and 19 minutes
- Emissions: 0.0 lb of CO2-e
Walk Route
- Distance: 0.99 miles
- Duration: 20 miles
- Emissions: 0.0 lb of CO2-e
My Example
Displayed is a route from my home to school using different modes of transportation.
The modes of transportation I chose was a bicycle and a commuter vehicle since these options would be my most realistic options.
Bicycle Route
- Distance 2.24 miles
- Duration: 13 minutes
- Emissions: 0.0 lb of CO2-e
Commuter Vehicle Route
- Duration: 2.24 miles
- Duration: 9 minutes
- Emissions: 1.58 lb of CO2-e
Now knowing my exact contribution in my transportation carbon footprint, I think it's best to ride my bike to school.
Final thoughts
Students participating in the GIS activity can strengthen their sustainable thinking by visualization their impact. This can encourage students to make better choices on their mode of transportation while applying geospatial technology. Learning GIS can teach students a new way of spatial thinking!
Sources
City of Los Angeles Open GIS data via http://geohub.lacity.org/
Cal Berkeley household carbon footprint via https://www.dropbox.com/s/xqfduksgt6cmema/Jones-Kammen-2014-Zip-City-County-Results.xlsx?dl=0
Center for Climate Energy Solutions via https://www.c2es.org/content/reducing-your-transportation-footprint/
Metro GIS Data via https://developer.metro.net/docs/gis-data/overview/
Map My Emissions via https://mapmyemissions.com/home
SCAG GIS Open Data Portal via http://gisdata-scag.opendata.arcgis.com/