Oversalting in Hamilton: Revolutionizing the salt paradigm

How might we reduce the impact of road salt in the Hamilton Harbour?

Executive Summary

Adrian Chan, Eric Liu, John Yeom, Sarah De Buono

Infastructure and Built Environment I1

Mission Statement

Our mission is to implement sustainable and best management practices regarding deicing salt usage within Hamilton Harbour. This is accomplished by combining current resources and new designs to modify current practices. This will reduce deicing salt leakage into water runoff, ultimately revitalizing aquatic ecosystems and protecting infastructure.

Description

Our proposed solution is to modify current de-icing practices through the implementation of a new gritter design (or a salt spreader) . The new gritter design will address any uneven salting due to mechanical limitations which is responsible for the large excess amounts of deicing salts used on a regular basis.

Our main objective is to reduce the amount of de-icing salt that is used, and consequently, the amount reaching waterways, infastructure, and vegetation. There is a common misconception that more de-icing salt means better performance. However this is not the case, as most of the excess de-icing salt affecting infastructure and ecosystems come from private practices and oversalting of roadways. This solution will allow for more sustainable and cost-effective salting practices, and will be targeted mainly to the municipal government.


Our How Might We Question

How might we reduce the impact of road salt on Hamilton Harbour?


Human Centred Design


Our Research Findings

SDG Alignment

Case Studies and Findings

Revised Questions After Speaking to the Community


Our Timeline


Measuring Success

How will you and your team measure the success of your solution should it be implemented?

  1. To decrease the amount of de-icing salt reaching bodies of water

2. To maintain the main purpose for the use of de-icing salt

3. To be economically viable

4. To implement a refined approach to de-icing salt without detrimental long-term consequences


Our Solution Ideas

Include all 3 solution ideas and prototypes here!


Equitable and Inclusive Considerations


Project Viability

Solution 1: Social Media Campaign

Solution 2: Private Sector Certification (HRS)

Solution 3: Salt Spreader Regulator


Final Solution

Redesigned Salt Spreader with Injection Pipes

  • Our final solution is a redesign of the salt spreader on the back of salt trucks.
  • Our next steps will be to build a scaled prototype and implementation will work by phasing in the new designs. There will also need to be education for operators and the public of the new systems.

Our Pitch to Stakeholders


Our Experience with MacChangers

MacChangers allowed us to meet new people and work together to both learn about and get involved with the people of Hamilton. We learned more about the inner workings of the city and some of the organizations and their roles within the daily activities of the city. A major takeaway for us was the human-centered design process and how solutions to complex problems can be built together with the community for the benefit of everyone.We believe that our solution will be effective as it benefits all the affected parties such as citizens of Hamilton and the municipality without a tradeoff for safety, which is a very important point when considering the problem of oversalting.

Citations

Byrnes, T. K., Smith, C., & Solanki, B. (2022). (publication). Jurisdictional Review of Best Management Practices and Innovative Approaches to Minimize Impacts of Road Salting Practices to the Environment. Guelph: Ontario Agricultural College.

Canan turan. (2019, July 10). WHAT'S NEXT ? stock photo. https://media.istockphoto.com/id/1160934657/photo/whats-next.jpgs=612x612&w=0&k=20&c=aJrrlcPqE Nb3iiGljEliJlmJZPH75cToUVLlLtVYtCo=​

CBC. (2019, December 8). [Photograph of de-icing salt on walkway]. https://i.cbc.ca/1.5388755.1575835270!/fileImage/httpImage/salty-sidewalk-salt.jpg​

Earth.com. (2014, February 4). [Photograph of disk salt spreader on back of salt truck]. https://cff2.earth.com/uploads/2019/02/04125305/How-salt-trucks-keep-roads-safe%E2%80%A6-and-some-eco-friendly-alternatives.jpg

Krasula, M. (2020, May 21). Snow plow salting street in winter time. Orange truck deicing. stock photo [Photograph]. Getty Images. https://images.radio.com/aiu-media/GettyImages1222260595-2265b021-e5a1-4fc7-8762-3ab7b9e5c79f.jpg​

Marinas.com. (n.d.). [Photograph of Hamilton Harbour]. Retrieved March 21, 2023 from https://img.marinas.com/v2/6f9c19ec7ec9b9a9a04404b864c0b7b160963e34877e73b0ee43410b0330caaf.jpg​

Nantung, T. (2001, June 1). [Photograph of existing zero-velocity salt spreader]. https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/38889

United Nations. (n.d.). Goal 12 | Department of Economic and Social Affairs. United Nations. Retrieved March 31, 2023, from https://sdgs.un.org/goals/goal12

United Nations. (n.d.). Goal 14 | Department of Economic and Social Affairs. United Nations. Retrieved March 31, 2023, from https://sdgs.un.org/goals/goal14

Willowpix. (2017, March 31). Car Driver POV Expressway Snowplow Dump Truck Spreading Road Salt stock photo. https://encrypted-tbn2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSdw-v-lXwzH2PZYKFI91mN-wu2wRTJH3yfS30_SYL231z_g26i

MacChangers 2022/2023 Final Deliverable

Adrian Chan, Eric Liu, John Yeom, Sarah De Buono

Infastructure and Built Environment I1