ASABE Soil Erosion Research Symposium
SOIL EROSION RESEARCH UNDER A CHANGING CLIMATE
ASABE Soil Erosion Research Symposium Field Trip
We would like to express our sincere appreciation to the organizers of the 2023 ASABE Soil Erosion Symposium Field Tour for their commitment and hard work. Without your contribution and assistance this activity would not be possible.
Thank you to the following for coordinating field tour activities and tour materials:
- Lizandra Nieves Rivera - Watershed Program Manager - Grand Mesa, Uncompahgre and Gunnison National Forest, USDA-FS.
- Manuel Matos Rodríguez, State Soil Scientist, USDA-NRCS Caribbean Area
- Mario Rodriguez Acosta, State Resource Conservationist, USDA-NRCS Caribbean Area
- Dr. Eric Harmsen, UPRM Agricultural and Biosystems Engineering Professor.
- Ismael Pagán Trinidad, UPRM Civil Engineering Department Professor, and Director of Coastal Resilience Center.
- Dr. Carlos Ramos Sharron, UTX-Austin Geography and the Environment Department Professor.
Itinerary
Field Trip Map
Field Site 1
Hacienda Santa Rita. Description of resources of the Rio Loco watershed. Introduction and discussion of Guánica/Rio Loco project.
Field Site 2
Ajíes-Daguey flood control dams. Description of the Añasco watershed basin, resources, research, and projects.
Field Site 3
Stella-Playa Corcega Site. Introduction and description of the Puerto Rico Coastal Erosion Resource Concerns.
Site 1: Guánica-Rio Loco Watershed Projects
•Upper Watershed Coffee Region Conservation Practices: Yauco-Maricao Municipalities.
•Lower Watershed Coastal Plains Farming Lands: Lajas–Guánica Municipalities.
Presenters:
- Jaime Acevedo – Farm Owner and Former Oeste SWCD Board of Directors
- Mario Rodriguez – State Resource Conservations, USDA NRCS Caribbean Area NRCS
- Yilia Baucage – USDA NRCS Caribbean Area State Conservation Engineer, and Gabriel Roman, USDA-NRCS Civil Engineer
- Dr. Carlos Ramos Sharron – Research and solutions in the Rio Loco-Guanica Bay System
Priority Areas:
Upper Watershed Coffee Region
1 - Upland Guanica Bay Watershed Erosion / Run-off Control in the Coffee Growing Regions.
2 - Converting sun coffee to shaded coffee plantations.
3 - The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) Caribbean field office partnered with the NRCS in providing technical assistance to promote agro- forestry practices.
Over 28 upland farms participated.
Action 1 - Tree Planting for Coffee Shade
Action 2 - Run-off Control in the Coffee Growing Regions.
Erosion Caused by off-road vehicles driving thru coffee plantations.
Photos by NRCS
Partner Research's:
A - Quantification of runoff and erosion through rainfall simulation experiments and monitoring. Implementation and testing of erosion control methods.
B - Quantification of sediment production by landsliding [Partners: UPR-Río Piedras, UT-Austin, & Protectores de Cuencas Inc.; Funding provided by NASA & NFWF].
C. Sediment Mobilization by Hurricane-Driven Shallow Landsliding in a Wet Subtropical Watershed.
C. Land-based sediment sources and transport to southwest Puerto Rico coral reefs after Hurricane Maria, May 2017 to June 2018.
Monitoring and Results: Coffee Shade Canopy Development.
Photos courtesy of USFWS and Envirosurvey Inc.
Additional practices by voluntary conservation activities - Photos: Harry Maldonado, Soil Conservation Technician USDA-NRCS (retired)
A. Guánica - Río Loco Watershed Conservation
The Río Loco Watershed Project (RLWP) began in 2009 as a multiagency effort to support the US Coral Reef Task Force (USCRTF) Local Action Strategies (LAS) as identified in the Guánica Bay Watershed Management Plan. NRCS work seeks to address LAS at Río Loco related to land based sources of pollution by reducing loss of coral reef cover through the promotion and application of integrated watershed and land use management practices on agricultural lands.
Guánica-Rio Loco Watershed - Implemented Conservation Practices
Lower Watershed Coastal Plains Farmlands.
•Project directly impacted 11 farms at Guánica and 8 in Lajas.
•Private and Public land owned and rented to private farmers and ranchers.
•Farmers are losing land and excess nutrient rich sediment and topsoil is being exported to the Guánica Bay.
•Reservoirs, sedimentation retention and clean water transport.
•Reduced in-stream channel erosion and runoff.
B. Sediment Issues, Research and Solutions
Road cut slope erosion in an actively-cultivated tropical montane setting.
Runoff from the local Río Loco watershed was advected westward in a narrow band along the coast where its ecological impacts would be the greatest, and only appeared at mid-shelf reef sites following storms when winds were directed offshore.
Sediment geochemical sourcing combined with nearshore sediment traps are a powerful tool that can increase understanding about land-derived runoff sources, timing, and nearshore transport and guide watershed management and ecosystem restoration strategies.
Site 2: Añasco Watershed
A. Ajíes-Daguey Flood Control Dam's
- Welcome/Introduction: Puerto Rico Department of Natural and Environmental Resources (PRDNER) Representative.
- USDA-NRCS Engineers Yilia Baucage and Rolando Collazo (Welcome to Site and description of Ajies-Daguey Dam Projects) (10 min.)
In the late 1970’s, USDA‐SCS (now NRCS) completed the Environmental Impact Statement and Planning consultation process for the Añasco River Watershed Project that identified the need for flood protection structures in the watershed. Subsequently, construction for 2 new dams —Ajíes and Dagüey— was completed in the 1980’s. Both dams performed well during Hurricane Maria in Sept. 2017 and reduced flooding levels in the area. However, both dams suffered damages due to the activation of the Auxiliary Spillways. Dam repair designs are now complete, and construction is scheduled to begin in 2023 with funding from the NRCS Emergency Watershed Program. Further funding to prepare the planning and environmental assessments to rehabilitate and modernize these dams has been approved by NRCS through the REHAB program.
B. Rio Grande de Añasco Watershed Landslide and Sedimentation Research
Puerto Rico Department of Environemtal and Natural Resources (PRDENR) and USDA-NRCS Caribbean Area Ajíes and Daguey Flood Control Dam Projects
Researchers:
a. Hurricane Maria Precipitation Signature in Puerto Rico.
b. Hurricane Maria Landslide Density - slope failure locations.
c. Rio Grande de Añasco Sediment Plume landslide effects.
d. Slide-PR - Hurricane María landslide inventory, new high-resolution landslide susceptibility map, modern landslide guide for residents of Puerto Rico.
A. Hurricane Maria Precipitation Signature in Puerto Rico:
On the 20th of September 2017, Hurricane María dropped the highest island wide amount of daily precipitation ever recorded in Puerto Rico (records from 1898 onwards) with totals reaching up to 733 mm in 24 hours. Some of the highest rain totals were reported on the East-Central portions of the island, but also included portions of its western regions some of which were contained within the Río Grande de Añasco watershed [Images from Ramos-Scharrón and Arima, 2019].
Hurricane María triggered over 70,000 landslides throughout the island. Landslide hotspots included central and western portions of the island, including portions of the Río Grande de Añasco watershed. Landslides were mapped from high resolution aerial photography as a collaborative project between the Department of Geology at UPR-Mayaguez and the US Geological Survey.
Landslides triggered by Hurricane María, many of which developed into debris flow, resulted in loss of life and induced significant damage to both private property and infrastructure. [Left top photo by the USGS; all others by S Hughes in Naguabjo (top right), Naranjito (bottom left), and Barranquitas (bottom right)].
C1. Rio Grande de Añasco Sediment Plume
A significant portion of the sediment transported by the Río Grande de Añasco was thought to be generated by surface erosion occurring within farms in the headwater portions of the watershed. A 2014 study funded by UPR-Sea Grant and conducted as a collaborative effort between the Geological and Environmental Remote Sensing Laboratory of UPR-Mayaguez and UT-Austin, confirmed this by suggesting that surfaces devoid of vegetation for the purposes of agriculture, rock quarrying, and construction are responsible for the vast majority of the watershed’s sediment yield. The role of landslides and streambank erosion in producing sediments within this watershed is still unknown but thought to be significant.
Through a combination of remote sensing analyses and in-situ water quality observations, researchers from the GERS-UPR-Mayaguez and UT-Austin were able to establish that the Río Grande de Añasco exerts a major control in the concentration of suspended sediments in the Añasco and Mayaguez Bay during low and moderate streamflow conditions, but that during high streamflow conditions the river’s influence on water quality, and thus marine environments like corals, reaches the coastline of Rincón about 10 km to the north of the river outlet. [Photos by GERS-Lab; maps by Ramos-Scharrón et al. (2014)].
C2. Rio Grande de Añasco Sediment Plume landslide effects.
Río Grande de Añasco was one of the island-wide landslide hotspots with over 12,400 slope failures (top left maps). When delivered to the stream network (top right photo), sediments produced by landslides have deleterious effects on the island’s water resources. Sediments released by landsliding are believed to represent a key source of the sediment that accumulates in the Río Grande de Añasco’s various water reservoirs such as the Lago Yahuecas, which has been fully filled-in since the early 2000s (bottom left and right images). [Top left map prepared by S Hughes. Bottom left map prepared by C Ramos-Scharrón with data from Hughes et al. (2019).
d. SLIDES-PR is a multi-phase project launched by the Department of Geology UPR-Mayaguez one month after the passing of Hurricane María in 2017. The endeavor benefits from collaborative efforts with the USGS Landslide Hazards Group, USDA-NRCS, UC-Boulder Natural Hazards Center, and the Puerto Rico Junta de Planificación. Some significant products of this project include a Hurricane María landslide inventory of over 70,000 mass wasting sites, a new high-resolution landslide susceptibility map for the island, and a modern landslide guide for residents of Puerto Rico. These products have been used by FEMA to estimate Hurricane María’s landslide-related damages (>$280 million) and by the PR Departamento de Vivienda (Department of Housing) to prepare the $8.2 billion Puerto Rico Mitigation Action Plan (CDBG-MIT) The SLIDES-PR project also trains undergraduate and graduate students at UPR-Mayaguez on issues related to natural hazards. Ongoing efforts of the project include a collaborative investigation with the Caribbean Area NRCS soil survey office, collaborative NSF-funded research with Purdue University, bathymetric surveys, and the installation of a new real-time network of hydrological soil monitoring stations across the island.
High-resolution landslide susceptibility map
Hurricane María landslide maps were used as the basis for the development of an updated landslide susceptibility map for the entire island and a landslide prevention guide for local residents.
Modern landslide guide for residents of Puerto Rico.
C. The Añasco Watershed Flood Modeling Studies, Dr. Eric Harmsen- UPRM
The Añasco watershed is a large area in Puerto Rico that spans 143 square miles and includes several municipalities. A diverse range of landscapes, including urban, agricultural, and forested areas and a large coastal flood plain, characterizes it. The dominant land cover is mixed forest, cultivated, low-intensity developed areas, and the prevalent soil types are clay and clay loam. The watershed is home to four interconnected lakes and receives an average of 85 inches yearly rainfall. There is a USGS stream gauge located in the upper part of the watershed but none in the lower coastal plain. Several modeling studies were conducted in the watershed before Hurricane Maria.
Following Hurricane Maria, the University of Puerto Rico – Mayaguez (UPRM) and the City University of New York (CUNY) conducted a flood modeling study. The purpose of the study was to develop a numerical model using the GSSHA model to simulate flooding from extreme weather events, using Hurricane Maria as a case study. The model was calibrated using data from Hurricane Irma and validated with a similar storm in 2007. Storm surge was also included in the model but had a minimal effect on flood depths. The model was used to evaluate the impacts of flooding on critical infrastructure, such as water, electricity, and public schools, in the study area. The study found that the flood's recurrence interval was approximately 200 years, and the flood more severely impacted the water infrastructure than the electrical infrastructure. In the future, researchers aim to use machine learning and neural network techniques to improve the accuracy of rainfall estimates, allowing for rainfall prediction within a 48–72-hour timeframe. The method will allow for better forecasting of the depth and extent of flooding and its potential impact on critical infrastructure.
Hydrologic Model
The GSSHA is a process-based model, developed by the U.S. Army Engineer Research and Development Center (ERDC) Coastal and Hydraulics Laboratory (CHL), and is a multidimensional model that couples overland, surface, and subsurface flow. GSSHA simulates two-dimensional (2D) overland and groundwater flow, one dimension (1D) streamflow, and soil moisture. A feature of GSSHA is the inclusion of spatial and temporal precipitation, allowing the use of NEXRAD precipitation products. It should be mentioned that GSSHA is approved by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) for hydrologic modelling [ 66 ]. Some of the hydrological processes and approximations simulated in GSSHA are precipitation distribution, snowfall accumulation and melting, precipitation interception, overland water retention, infiltration, overland flow routing, evapotranspiration, soil moisture in the vadose zone, lateral groundwater flow, stream/ground water interaction, and exfiltration [ 67 ].
Comparison between maximum flooding depth in sub-watershed 1 using the observed USGS data vs. maximum flooding by simulating runoff in the sub-watershed 2 (upstream). Slide images left and right to compare.
Aerial imagery to compare the Añasco River Valley before and after Hurricane Maria - June-2017 (left) vs. September-2017 (right). Slide picture left and right. Source: Google Earth Pro.
Site 3 - Coastal Erosion Rincon - Playa Corcega, Stella Recreational Area
Chronic erosion problem as a result of natural processes and anthropogenic changes
Site 3 - Coastal Erosion Rincon - Playa Corcega, and other areas
Chronic erosion problem as a result of natural processes and anthropogenic changes
Rincon is a west coast municipality of Puerto Rico’s western coast that suffers from a chronic erosion problem as a result of natural processes and anthropogenic bad decisions that permitted the development of houses, hotels, condos and infrastructure on the maritime zone privatizing a public domain good. The continuous shoreline changes and erosion were exacerbated by the pass of hurricanes Irma and María and the usual winter swells resulting from cold fronts that make Rincón famous as a surfing destination. Rincón is home to the biggest waves of the Caribbean that can be ridden by locals and tourists during the winter months.
A. Presentation of coastal erosion research, education efforts and community engagement.
Ruperto Chaparro-Sea Grant Director, and Dr. Rene Esteves, Marine Extension Director/Research Coordinator, Sea Grant Puerto Rico.
Priority needs
In line with the National Sea Grant College Program’s focus areas, Puerto Rico program has identified the following priority needs as the most important ones for our region:
- Inventory and population studies of important coastal species and biological resources (e.g., fish, coral reef, seagrasses, mangroves, microbes)
- Studies that promote habitat restoration and reforestation (e.g., salt ponds, coral reefs, mangroves, wetlands, hydrographic basins)
- Impacts of climate change (e.g., sea level rise, flooding, increases in rainfall, storms and hurricanes, seawater temperature, erosion, species migration) on coastal areas
- Habitat connectivity and utilization (e.g., adjacent ecosystems, land-use planning)
- Development of environmental indicators and environmental/biological standards for public health (e.g., water quality, nutrients, sediments)
- Establishing the resilience capacity or limit of adaptive change of local communities frequently visited by tourists and resource users and their ability to adapt to climate change
- Assessment of the socio-economic impact of commercially and recreationally important marine organisms on local communities.
- Studies on the impacts of invasive/exotic species and pathogens (e.g., natural stressors, lionfish, microbes)
- Establishing baselines of commercial and recreational marine organisms (e.g., fish, conch) to obtain reliable estimates of size and catch trends
- Habitat mapping and identification of critical areas (e.g., spawning aggregation sites, coral reefs)
- Physical models that link watershed and coastal processes in order to address and test a wide variety of issues (climate change, habitat migration, management of ecosystems, hazards, and anthropogenic influences).
Historical data and photos from 1930 clearly demonstrate the changes along the coast. Erosion issues on the coast have always occurred due to natural processes. However, impacts have been aggravated by excessive legal and illegal development on the coast, and the recurrence of extreme weather events occurring as an effect of climate change.
UPRM - Civil Engineering and Surveying Department and the Coastal Resilience Center
The Department of Civil Engineering and Surveying was established dreaming on investing in education to support the social and economic development of Puerto Rico. During this time, extraordinary accomplishments have been the outcome of all the efforts this Institution has returned to our society. We proudly have developed for over a century with areas of expertise in Structures, Construction, Transportation, Geotechnical, Environmental and Water Resources and Surveying and Topography. We also focus on applying best practices to provide sustainable, resilient and safe civil built and natural infrastructure to our community. You are welcome to visit our department web page ( https://www.uprm.edu/inci/ ).
At present time, we offer six academic programs: two undergraduate programs (BS in Civil Engineering (1913) and BS in Surveying and Topography(1978)), and four graduate programs (three masters programs with thesis, project or course options, and a Ph.D.). The graduate programs focus on options in Environmental, Structures, Transportation, Geotechnical, and Construction. The Civil Engineering and the Surveying and Topography Programs are accredited by ABET. Our graduate program persistently attracts graduate students from Puerto Rico and abroad. The master’s program was created in 1966. The Ph.D. program began in 1993.
Overall, our Department has grown to: educate our students, develop the research needed to create new knowledge, provide the necessary technology to lead the sustainable and effective urban development, provide the sensitivity to protect and restore the environment, and educate the most capable labor force to lead the socio-economic development in Puerto Rico and elsewhere. Our faculty, administrative personnel, students, and partners are committed to excellence by facing the new challenges of the profession and forming the most competitive professionals, citizens, and human beings to serve our people and resolve civil engineering and surveying problems.
The UPRM Coastal Resilience Center (CRC) sponsored by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) conducts research and education to help the community by transferring state of practice knowledge to stakeholders (students, faculty, professionals, first responders, and workforce) through formal (curriculum, internships, student projects, undergraduate research) and professional (workshops, seminars, lectures, short courses, webinars) learning experiences ( https://www.uprm.edu/inci/crc-2-mod/ ). It will serve as a vehicle to engage the community as a whole to understand and learn its members’ roles and responsibilities in providing resilient infrastructure. The project helps the community understand better various stages in coastal infrastructure hazard prevention, preparedness, mitigation, response, recovery, and adapt. It focuses on understanding the natural phenomenology, the engineering methodologies to address the level of risk the infrastructure is exposed to, the engineering methodologies and technology to analyze and predict the level of resistance and vulnerability the infrastructure and community is exposed to, the sustainable and resilient alternatives available at the state of the practice or state of the art to cope with risks and vulnerabilities. The project motivates students and faculty to students and professionals into homeland security careers and practice.
USDA NONDISCRIMINATION STATEMENT
In accordance with Federal civil rights law and U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) civil rights regulations and policies, the USDA, its Agencies, offices, and employees, and institutions participating in or administering USDA programs are prohibited from discriminating based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, gender identity (including gender expression), sexual orientation, disability, age, marital status, family/parental status, income derived from a public assistance program, political beliefs, or reprisal or retaliation for prior civil rights activity, in any program or activity conducted or funded by USDA (not all bases apply to all programs). Remedies and complaint filing deadlines vary by program or incident.
Persons with disabilities who require alternative means of communication for program information (e.g., Braille, large print, audiotape, American Sign Language, etc.) should contact the responsible Agency or USDA's TARGET Center at (202) 720-2600 (voice and TTY) or contact USDA through the Federal Relay Service at (800) 877-8339. Additionally, program information may be made available in languages other than English.
To file a program discrimination complaint, complete the USDA Program Discrimination Complaint Form, AD-3027, found online at How to File a Program Discrimination Complaint, and at any USDA office or write a letter addressed to USDA and provide in the letter all of the information requested in the form. To request a copy of the complaint form, call (866) 632-9992. Submit your completed form or letter to USDA by: (1) mail: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Office of the Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights, 1400 Independence Avenue, SW, Washington, D.C. 20250-9410; (2) fax: (202) 690-7442; or (3) email: program.intake@usda.gov.
USDA is an equal opportunity provider, employer, and lender.
Story Map Prepared by Lizandra Nieves Rivera, USDA-FS GMUG Watershed Program Manager, and Manuel Matos Rodriguez, USDA-NRCS Caribbean Area State Soil Scientist