Visualising future tree planting in Northumberland

Exploring future scenarios with the Great Northumberland Forest

Introduction

The Great Northumberland Forest Partnership aims to increase woodland cover. We have created six visualisations of potential landscapes. They show what an increase in woodland cover in different settings might look like in the future.

There are six different viewpoints and they range from uplands to the coast. Each shows four different timeframes: today, after five years, after 15 years and after 40 years.

  • They show how sensitive future changes could increase tree cover,
  • They follow the principle of, "right tree, right place",
  • They are general examples; they are not site-specific.

We'd like to start a conversation about what future landscapes might look like.


Landscape 1 - uplands

Today - this is the starting picture, taken in early May. There is an upland burn in the centre of the picture and two sloping hills left and right. In the distance is heather moorland. Around the stream are a few scattered broadleaves and at the top of either hill are conifer forests.

This type of landscape is typically over 250m above sea level, with gently rolling hills. Just like here, upland burns separate the hills, and the features can sometimes be hidden by plantations. The views are of a mixture of heather moorland, peat mires, coniferous plantations and open grassland for hill grazing. The landscape generally is uninhabited, apart from occasional farmsteads and villages. It can be a changing scene when areas of forest are felled and restocked.

Beyond this viewpoint, in this type of landscape, there might be small areas of more sheltered grazing near the farm buildings (in-bye pasture).

In 5 years...

This is one potential view of the landscape in 5 years' time, where actions have been taken to increase tree cover.

A few birch trees have started to colonise around the sheltered burn. These are 'pioneer' species that are the first to appear and are able to grow in challenging environments. They start to form a connection with the existing broadleaved trees around the burn, providing summer shade for the burn. This benefits in particular fish, as cooler waters can hold more oxygen. The trees and shrubs will also help in slowing the flow of rain water, which can help reduce flood risk downstream.

Lower grazing rates, which go hand-in-hand with the increase in tree and shrub growth, will result in other changes in the ground vegetation. Species like heather would become bigger plants.

In 15 years ...

In a longer timeframe, the birch trees are now well established. They are quite fast growing species. There are still patches of open ground, a mosaic of scattered trees, heather and bracken.

There are also scattered conifers growing, the seeds probably blowing in from the surrounding forest. One of the conifers is a Scots Pine, which is thought to be a native conifer in Northumberland.

At the top of the slope, the broadleaved trees have started to soften the visual edge of the conifer forests.

What we are seeing generally is a progression of the pattern that was established after 5 years. Allowing for "natural colonisation" means that we don't have the visual impacts of plastic tree tubes, (and the task of collecting tubes in again). But, if this was more of a planting scheme, then the tree tube factor would need to be considered.

In 40 years.

The burn is now a well-wooded feature in the foreground, but the heather moorland is still visible beyond. Particularly in winter when the birch trees drop their leaves the view will be open.

With more time, the canopy would continue to grow and close, providing more shade for the stream and shelter for wildlife in this exposed upland environment. It is not quite a continuous canopy cover, because we think changes with upland weather conditions and a short growing season would take longer.

Again, we are seeing the progression through time of the images before.

Other self-seeded species that might appear would be rowan (mountain ash) and hawthorn. There would also be slightly different ground vegetation around the trees - plants that grow alongside trees in this upland habitat. For example, bilberry and crowberry, following a reduction in grazing.

The trees, shrubs, ground plants and soils are also, of course, a valuable carbon store. This is alongside the benefits like reduced flood risk, improved water quality and an increase in biodiversity. Any dead wood, which will become an increasing feature over a 40 year timespan and beyond, becomes a really useful place for insects, fungi and other organisms to live, so is still part of an ecosystem - as well as starting to form the soils of the future.

Have a go at comparing the present day with the artist's impression in 40 years' time by moving the slider left and right

Landscape 2 - productive forest on upland fringe

Today - this is the starting picture, taken in early May. In the foreground is farmland which leads down to a river in the valley bottom, which already has broadleaved trees around it.

On the far side of the river and over a road starts a more upland fringe slope. The rows of conifer trees that have just been planted are visible as small green stripes. There is a stream flowing past pasture fields grazed by animals, down to some cottages on the right of the image. Mixed tree species edge the lower part of this burn.

On the horizon are some existing conifer forests and some mixed woodland, with a quarry on the top left.

Typical of this upland fringe landscape , the views are quite expansive. The hills are flat-topped and elongated. There are large-scale, geometrically laid out coniferous plantations. There are tracts of grassland pastures. Dry stone walls are used for enclosures. Typical in this landscape are archaeological remains, hinted at by the earthworks and line of stones where this viewpoint is taken from. The altitude is about 250m above sea level, compared to the first location, which was higher.

In 5 years ...

The plantation woodland is maturing, following the approved planting plan and forest design.

The species in the lower compartments are Douglas Fir and a mix of Sitka Spruce / Norway Spruce. The edges of the planting parcels follow the contours of the land.

There is an open area in the middle of the view. This was left unplanted, to protect the species-rich marshy grassland habitat. Some Scots Pine is planted to the left of that.

Towards the horizon, Sitka Spruce is the main forest tree, with some mixed broadleaved trees visible on the right-hand side. From this distance, we can't see any plastic tree tubes and deer fencing, but broadleaved trees would probably need them.

The farmland in the foreground and to the right of the picture is grazed - supporting the local economy and communities, along with the forestry. The earthworks here, evidence of humans in the landscape from centuries ago, is also left open.

In 15 years ...

We are seeing the progression of the tree growth. Broadleaf trees are growing on the lower slopes and around the forest edges. They help to soften the more angular of the forestry compartments.

Trees now dominate the skyline and open areas, kept open within the planting plan, are now screened by the surrounding growing trees.

The trees will be storing carbon as well as slowing the flow of rainwater reaching the burns and rivers.

In 40 years.

At this point the forest is ready, or nearly ready, for harvesting - when the landscape would change again.

We are seeing the progression through time of the growth of the trees in the planting plan.

Landscape 3 - a farm in mid Northumberland

Today. There is farmland in this picture, with grass growing. The fields are separated by hedges and a wide margin has been left around the hedges for wildlife. In the distance are some established broadleaf trees bordering a road, or it could be a river. We can't see from this distance, but some of these trees might be ash trees. Some telegraph wires cross the field in the distance, on the right-hand side.

Key characteristics of this type of landscape is the rolling, mixed farmland with generally open views broken up by the remains of hedgerows. Farm woodland already includes occasional shelterbelts and riparian woods. There might also be heritage in this area, perhaps medieval ridge and furrow ploughing patterns or deserted settlement, for example.

In 5 years ...

The hedges have increased in height. There is a taller tree in the hedge about every 10 metres. The fenced enclosures have been planted with a few different species of tree. In each one a major tree, perhaps an oak tree - is planted alongside companion species like elder or hawthorn. These earlier establishing trees provide nectar, pollen and berries for insects.

Using small fenced enclosures means there will be less nibbling on the young saplings by deer. However, plastic tree tubes might still be needed, until the tree is about 10 years old - to protect from rabbits and voles.

The farmland will still to be grazed, maybe by hardy cattle, which can stay outside even in winter without needing a barn and extra feeding. The grazing animals benefit from the shelter and shade that the trees provide, both in the fenced areas and the taller hedges.

The long term aim of this is to create something that looks like parkland, but with space for grazing animals.

In 15 years ...

Here we are seeing the impact of the hedges left to reach their potential - the distant fields are now almost hidden. In hot weather the grazing animals would shelter under the shade of the trees. They might also eat some of them, getting extra nutrients and minerals.

In the foreground we can see the trees and shrubs in the fenced off enclosures are growing well. The parkland-type landscape is starting to form.

It is possible that, once the trees and shrubs are well established, the fenced enclosures are removed, but we have left them in this imaginary visualisation.

In 40 years ...

This is what the parkland / wood pasture effect might look like. The tree canopies don't touch each other, so there is open space between each one. The grass still grows and can be grazed - a continuation of traditional livestock grazing. Some of the tree species, like oak, are still just in their infancy, with the potential to live for many hundreds of years. These are the "veteran trees of tomorrow".

If there were ash trees along the road or river, it is likely that ash die-back has affected them by now. Still, any dead wood that it is safe to leave is also a good habitat for invertebrates, fungi and birds like owls and woodpecker.

Overall the trees provide valuable habitat, for a wider ecosystem, as well as shelter and shade for the farm business. The soils are improved by tree growth, with a better soil structure, water holding and carbon storing capacity.

The hedge that separates the fields has really matured, screening the fields behind are hidden. The telegraph wires are still there, but are less visible. The hedge makes an interesting corridor for animals and becomes part of an ecological network.

The trees will all be:

  • storing carbon,
  • slowing the flow of rainwater reaches the rivers (and so reducing flood risk downstream),
  • providing shade and shelter for the farm animals - this might become more and more important under climate change scenarios of hot summers and squally winters,
  • wider benefits for wildlife - pollinators, mammals, birds - a whole food web,
  • trees near a stream or river will be providing a cooling effect on the water,
  • and helping with keeping soil on the land.

The loss of veteran trees and historical wood pasture or parklands is something to think about as a result of climate change. Over time, we may have to change the types of species we plant, so that they are suitable for the growing conditions they will see in their lifetime.

Landscape 4 - a site near to where people live

Today - this grassy field is grazed by horses. We can see houses and trees in gardens in the distance, along the horizon. The buildings are all probably about 50 years old, but some to the very left of the picture are older. The field has a single species beech hedge to the left, next to a road.

In the dip between the hill in the foreground and the houses beyond is a small stream.

This wider area was influenced by opencast or drift mining in the 1900s. So, some evidence about the heritage of this area no longer exists. Some villages that developed to work on early mines in the first part of the 1900s were removed by later mining, along with farm buildings and ancient woodland. So, roundabout this area, the landscapes are on restored sites. The first restorations, near here, were very geometric, with pasture and conifer blocks in rectangles. Later restorations were more sympathetic and added distinctive features.

This pocket that isn't on a reclaimed site, is not far from the coast, and is about 15m above sea level. There are only a few viewpoints within this landscape because it is generally quite flat with gently rolling areas.

In 5 years ...

A few broadleaf species have been planted here, at quite a low density, and people of all ages are exercising on paths and desire-lines. They may even have volunteered to help plant some of these trees.

The species have blossom and, in autumn they will have berries - that will help wildlife such as bees and birds find food and shelter.

They aren't shown in this artist's impression, but in reality, these trees would probably be planted in green plastic tree tubes. This helps prevent rabbits and voles eating the precious trees. Normally by about year 10 the tree tubes can be removed and hopefully re-used on another site.

In 15 years ...

We are seeing the growth of the trees over time - although we can still see the houses in the distance.

People are still enjoying this area, getting the physical health and mental health benefits of exercising in nature. There may also be opportunities for educational access, perhaps through the local school or U3A groups.

In 40 years.

The species that were planted are reaching their full height and spread.

The dappled trees haven't closed in, so the view is still of one that is on the edge of a village.

We would want the paths to be open to people of all abilities throughout the lifetime of this woodland.

The trees all store carbon, both in what we see above ground, but also in their roots. Their leaves will catch rainwater and reduce the speed that it reaches the stream.

Landscape 5 - near the coast

Today - we have grazed farmland in the foreground and in the middle distance of the picture. In the distance is ungrazed grassland. There are six wind turbines on the horizon, as well as two small lakes. There is an electricity pylon on the right hand side of the picture with the cables running across the view left-right.

There are already some trees in this landscape, acting as shelterbelts for the farmland. In the foreground we can see small deciduous copses.

This type site is about 45m above sea level. It is also a few miles inland from the coast, which is just behind the horizon. This is looking towards land that has been reclaimed after mining - the lake and the trees were not there about 50 years ago. In fact, the restoration probably happened around 20 years ago. In this type of landscape, infrastructure like pylons and more recent wind turbines are a feature.

In 5 years ...

In the foreground some pioneer species like birch are establishing, although from this view point the vista has been kept open, like an avenue.

The fields in the centre of the image are still grazed, but now with cattle instead of sheep. A new plantation has been planted on the right-hand side.

In the distance we can still see the horizon, but the rougher land now has scattered gorse, willow and other scrub species developing. Also there are broadleaf trees around the lake. Gorse and willow are a useful source of early pollen for queen bees. This type of habitat is also ideal for birds like owls and other birds of prey.

In 15 years ...

The biggest visual change is the birch trees in the foreground. We can still see the farmland in the centre and in the distance, the rougher ground's scrub habitat has developed further.

The scrub will be a valuable area of biodiversity and is an ecosystem that has a whole food web - from small invertebrates, up to hunting raptors.

In 40 years.

We are seeing the development of the birch trees in the foreground - which are now middle-aged trees. They are also acting as a visual screen for the electricity pylon from this viewpoint. The line of the avenue has been kept open.

In the distance, self-seeded trees have established themselves in the scrub area. The lake is now almost hidden in the landscape.

The farmland area is still grazed with hardy cattle.

This type of community woodland where the photograph is taken from provides benefits for nature, habitat connectivity, carbon storage, flood risk reduction and for the local community.

Landscape 6 - a site near to where people live

Today - this area is amenity grassland on the edge of housing. There is a mown path through the grass, but in the longer grass, species like hawthorn and willow have established themselves. We can see a telegraph pole on the right-hand side. The row of semi-detached houses we can see are probably around 90 years old.

The landscapes around here are generally flat with some gentle summits, so no big views that go on for miles. We are about 20m above sea level. The geology was previously worked for coal, among some of the first places in the area to be worked.

There is a railway line just out of sight, but you might hear it if you stood here. Passenger services stopped on that line in the 1960s as part of the Beeching cuts, but part of the system was kept for serving local collieries. It is now being restored for passengers under a large railway project.

In 5 years ...

This is still an area for people to walk in, play in, and enjoy. We would want the paths to be open to people of all abilities throughout the lifetime of this woodland.

This picture is spring, so the trees have blossom. Birds and other wildlife are more and more interested in this area - we can see two birds flying in the sky.

To the right, two rows of fruit trees have been planted. This mini, community orchard acts as a visual screen for the telegraph pole from this spot. We can see that at this age, the trees are protected from rabbit, vole and deer damage through the tree tubes. These tubes will need removing about year 10.

We can still see the houses in the distance as the area still has an 'open' feel.

In 15 years ...

The mini orchard on the right-hand side is now producing fruit for people to pick and enjoy, and the area can still be used for walking.

The hawthorn and willow shrubs that were already here have matured. They also now have flowers and berries, useful for lots of wildlife, as well as providing nest sites for birds.

The site has kept its open character, so we can still see the houses in the distance.

In 40 years.

We are seeing a continuation of the trees growing from before. All the trees are more mature.

The site still has its open character and we can see local people enjoying the fruit picking and playing.

Former industrial sites and places on the edge of existing settlements have potential to have benefits for nature, habitat connectivity, carbon storage, flood risk reduction and the local community.


This StoryMap is designed to start conversations with people about future landscape change and the multiple benefits that can be achieved by the right trees in the right places.


Contact

Contact us with any comments or thoughts! You can email us at enquiries.forest@northumberland.gov.uk.

Or fill in our 3 (anonymous!) questions below. Thank you!

Microsoft Forms


Use this map to find out which area of Northumberland you live in.

There are 11 areas, called National Character Areas. You can find out more about these areas on  this website  (new webpage hosted by Natural England).

We have written some landscape advice and recommendations for each area.

Use the magnifying glass in the top left-hand corner of the map to find out where you are interested in. Or the zoom in and out buttons in the bottom right-hand corner.

Then follow the links to read a 2-page guide of advice from specialists in Northumberland.

References and Links

The Great Northumberland Forest web pages on Northumberland County Council's website  Northumberland County Council - Great Northumberland Forest 

The Great Northumberland Forest's partnership StoryMap, which maps the areas of the county with the greatest potential. Features like landscape and surveys for special habitats, species or peat soils need fieldwork and discussions with land managers, so the map is not a planting plan, just a broad indication of initial potential  Woodland Creation Potential - Northumberland 

A similar StoryMap for the National Park area of Northumberland  Woodland Creation 

Existing landscape planning documents on Northumberland County Council's website (under "Environment and Landscape") from 2010  Northumberland County Council - Studies, evidence, reports and guidance 

A  Landscape Sensitivity and Capacity Study  (2013) for the Northumberland Coast National Landscape. Its focus was mostly on wind energy, housing, and caravan / camping / chalet sites, although it does include a review of the 2010 study mentioned above. It highlights opportunities for landscape enhancement and mitigation, including trees, hedges and shelterbelts.

The National Character Area (NCA) profiles - information about the key characteristics, recent changes and landscape trends and landscape attributes  National Character Area profiles - GOV.UK (www.gov.uk) 

Statements of Priorities for countryside stewardship for each National Character Area. For example, this can include an indication of where in-field trees, hedges and field margins are a high priority generally in that area. Each statement includes information about bringing existing woods into management, new tree planting, and the maintenance of landscape features that add to the area's sense of place  Statements of priorities: Countryside Stewardship - GOV.UK (www.gov.uk) 

The 5th UK Forestry Standard (section 6 in particular deals with landscape)  The UK Forestry Standard (publishing.service.gov.uk) 

Landscape Ecology on the Forest Research web pages  Landscape ecology - Forest Research 

 Perceptions of Landscape Change  (March 2022) research by Research Box - online focus groups ran in Northumberland

Woodland Creation Guide (2022) from the Woodland Trust  Woodland Creation Guide - Woodland Trust 

See side-by-side historical maps with modern maps or aerial maps on the National Library of Scotland website  https://maps.nls.uk/geo/explore/side-by-side 

Have a go at comparing the present day with the artist's impression in 40 years' time by moving the slider left and right