September 8th, 2014 flash flooding
Intense flash flooding caused by Hurricane Norbert remnants, mostly in the Phoenix metro area, set one-day record rainfall
Phoenix residents help someone trapped inside a car on September 8, 2014 (103rd Avenue and Lower Buckeye Road in Tolleson). From: The Arizona Republic
What happened? Why was this event so significant?
Remnants from Hurricane Norbert interacted with a low-pressure system to produce very intense rainfall during the early morning through midday of September 8, 2014 in the Phoenix and Tucson metro areas. The amount of rain produced in Phoenix during a 12-hour span was rare (<1% chance of occurring), but for areas such as Tempe, Mesa or Chandler it was an extremely rare event (<0.1% chance of occurring). This storm closed major highways and schools, flooded many homes, and caused multiple swift-water rescues. Unfortunately, fast-flowing washes in Tucson drowned two commuters.
Para la versión en español de este StoryMap, haz click aquí .
Flooded section of I-10 near 43rd in Phoenix that stranded several dozen vehicles due to a faulty pump system. From: The Arizona Republic
Meteorology
The average rainfall during the Monsoon (6/15-9/30) in Phoenix is 2.71 inches . But, sometimes the remnants of hurricanes or tropical cyclones can increase this amount (click here to learn more details). These events are uncommon, but once they do occur, can cause record-breaking rainfall and paralyze cities, such as in 2014.
The photo on the right shows the flooded neighborhood around Emerald Park in Mesa, Arizona, where 200 homes were flooded and residents had to evacuate
From: The Arizona Republic
Hurricane Norbert was formed on September 1st and significantly weakened by September 7th as it encountered cooler waters . The loop below shows its movement along the Mexican coast.
Hurricane Norbert's progression from September 4th to 9th, 2018. From: NOAA's NEDIS archive
The moist remnants associated with the weakened Hurricane Norbert (see loop below) were then steered towards Arizona (green arrow, right). This was made possible by a low-pressure system (blue L, right) off the California/Oregon coast.
Loop of total water vapor from September 7th to 9th, 2014. Hurricane Norbert is clearly seen rotating counterclockwise off the Mexican coast. From: CIMSS's MIMIC-TPW1
During the early morning hours of September 8th, 2014, Hurricane Norbert's remnants and instability from the low-pressure system formed two mesoscale convective systems (MCSs).
These systems merged and produced heavy rainfall in less than 12 hours. This lead to flash flooding throughout Phoenix and Tucson!
The loop on the right shows the progression of the MCSs from September 7th at 19:00 to September 8th at 16:00.
From: GOES-West Infrared Band, NWS Phoenix
Rainfall
Phoenix, 12-hour totals
The rainfall totals from September 8, 00:00 to 12:00 in the Phoenix metro from the Maricopa County ALERT network is shown in the image below. It is incredible to see that most of the Phoenix metro received more than 2 inches of rain in 12 hours.
According to the data, stations around the Sky Harbor International Airport (black rectangle) received 3.30 inches in 7 hours while a site in Chandler (purple rectangle) received >5.5 inches in 12 hours.
The Maricopa County Flood Control District estimated that the volume of water produced by this storm (261,233 acre-feet) could almost fill Horseshoe Reservoir AND Bartlett Reservoir (287,400 acre-feet) . That's a lot of water!
Phoenix, hourly rates at selected stations
The bulk of the rain occurred from 02:00 to 10:00, and peaked during the early hours (02:00-04:00) as illustrated below.
01 / 04
1
Carriage Lane Park, Mesa, AZ (ALERT 6520)
Most intense rain occurred at 03:00 (almost 2 inches/hour), with constant rain throughout the morning until 11:00. This station totaled 5.28 inches in 9 hours.
2
Old Crosscut Canal, Phoenix, AZ (ALERT 4745)
Most intense rain occurred at 02:00 (almost 2 inches/hour) and continued to rain until 06:00. This station totaled 3.42 inches in 4 hours.
3
Maryvale Municipal Golf Course, Phoenix, AZ (ALERT 4760)
Most intense rain occurred at 02:00 (a little more than one inch), with constant rain throughout the morning until 05:00. This station totaled 3.07 inches in 4 hours.
4
Salt River @ 67th Ave, Laveen Village, AZ (ALERT 5500)
Most intense rain occurred at 04:00 (almost 1.5 inches/hour), with constant rain throughout the morning until 08:00. This station totaled 2.75 inches in 6 hours.
Tucson, 12-hour totals
The rainfall totals from September 8th, 00:00 to 12:00 in the Tucson metro from the Pima County ALERT network is shown in the image below. We can see that most of the rain was concentrated around midtown, Catalina foothills, Oro Valley, Saddlebrooke and Mt. Lemmon.
Tucson, hourly rates at selected stations
Compared to Phoenix, most of the rain occurred from 08:00 to 12:00, and peaked from 09:00-11:00 (depending on location).
01 / 03
1
Samaniego Peak (ALERT 1130)
Most intense rain occurred at 09:00 (almost 2 inches/hour), with constant rain throughout the morning until 13:00. This station totaled 4.14 inches in 6 hours.
2
Oro Valley Public Works (ALERT 1230)
Most intense rain occurred at 11:00 (almost 2 inches/hour), with constant rain throughout the morning until 13:00. This station totaled 3.46 inches in 4 hours.
3
Finger Rock Wash at Skyline Drive (ALERT 2390)
Most intense rain occurred at 09:00 (almost 1.5 inches/hour), with constant rain throughout the morning until 13:00. This station totaled 1.85 inches in 5 hours.
Runoff
What was the hydrologic response in the metro and surrounding areas? We'll show you the evolution from September 7th at 00:00 to September 9th at 23:59 for four streamflow stations:
- Verde River near Scottsdale, a large tributary of the Salt River, located northeast of the Phoenix metro,
- Indian Bend Wash at Curry Road, a small tributary of the Salt River, located inside the Phoenix metro,
- Salt River at Priest Drive, a large tributary of the Gila River, located just east of Sky Harbor International airport, and
- Gila River near Estrella Parkway, downstream station located southwest of Phoenix metro.
In the US, we measure the volume of water flowing in a river in cubic feet per second (cfs). The easiest way to imagine this is 1 cubic foot being the size of a basketball.
One cubic foot of water is about 7.5 gallons, and 1 gallon weighs approximately 8 pounds. So, 1 cubic foot per second is the equivalent of a basketball weighing 60 pounds passing by every second!
01 / 04
1
Verde River near Scottsdale
Site outside of Phoenix metro. The hydrograph (volume of water over time) above shows that discharge peaked with about 1,500 cubic feet/second on 9/8 at 08:45.
2
Indian Bend Wash at Curry Road
Site in metro area. The hydrograph for this station shows a similar pattern to the previous station, but it peaked with almost 4,000 cubic feet/second on 9/8 at 09:30.
3
Salt River at Priest Drive
Site downstream from previous station, which is located near Sky Harbor International Airport.
This hydrograph also shows a similar patter to the last two stations, but largest peak flow here carried about 7,000 cubic feet/second on 9/8 at 07:20.
4
Gila River at Estrella Parkway
Site southwest of metro area. The hydrograph shows that this site had the largest peak flow (almost 10,000 cubic feet/second) on 9/8 at 15:30.
The water flowing from the mountains, arroyos or streets ended up here and continued flowing downstream (west).
Damages
The large amount of rain in such a short period of time caused major flash flooding in the Phoenix and Tucson metro areas. This situation was worsened by the timing of the storm; it rained on a Monday during the early morning hours through lunch time.
In Phoenix, five major highways were closed stranding commuting residents, 23 schools closed and 16,500 customers lost power . More than 3,400 emergency calls were answered in a 10 hour span . Moreover, residences near Emerald Park in Mesa were inundated due to a pump system failure . Insurance companies rejected residents' claims since they didn't have flood insurance and, ultimately, had to sue the city. Mesa settled for $1.6 million in early 2020 . Repair and cleanup of highways and streets cost $18 million and insurance companies paid $15 million in claims. According to a Maricopa County Flood Control District report , this event was rare (<1% chance of occurring), especially in areas such as Tempe, Mesa or Chandler (<0.1% chance of occurring).
01 / 06
1
I-10 at 43rd Avenue
This area had the most dramatic flooding from the storm. According to ADOT, pumps along the road failed to turn on , which created a mini-lake in this section of I-10. The pumps were manually turned on until 7am , but several vehicles were already underwater as they tried to pass through.
Photo from The Arizona Republic
2
Circle K, south of 1-10/43rd
Ceiling covering gas pumps was damaged due to the large rain amounts
Photo from The Arizona Republic
3
Harris Drive neighborhood in Mesa, north of US-60
One of the neighborhoods that was flooded by the overflowing retention basin in Emerald Park.
Photo from The Arizona Republic
4
Stapely Drive neighborhood in Mesa, north of US-60
Another neighborhood northwest of Emerald Park that was affected by the faulty pump system.
Photo from The Arizona Republic
5
67th Ave/Bethany Home Rd
Pedestrians walking along flooded streets in the West Valley
Photo from The Arizona Republic
6
Indian Bend Wash horse sculptures, Scottsdale
Indian Bend Wash, a flood control project finalized in the 80s, drained Scottsdale's streets extremely well and kept neighborhoods from flooding .
Photo from The Arizona Republic
In Tucson, no major damage was reported, but there were plenty of swift-water rescues. Unfortunately, a 53 year-old female drowned when her car submerged under 12 feet of water as she tried to drive through Alamo Wash. Outside of Tucson, a 76 year-old female drowned as her husband drove through Cadillac Wash.
01 / 05
1
W Rudasill/N Oracle, Tucson
A man tried to drive through Pima Wash and instead was swept downstream. Three firefighters had to rescue him. There were 30 swift-water rescues that day !
Photo from Dan Marries twitter account
2
E. Calle Betelgeux/Alamo Wash
Firefighters tried to rescue a 53-year old driver out of Alamo Wash twice, but the current was too fast and deep.
Photo from Arizona Daily Star
3
W Hardy Road
Two cars were stuck after trying to drive through a wash. One driver was still in the car and needed to be rescued by firefighters.
Photo from Tucson Local Media
4
La Cholla Bridge/Cañada del Oro Wash
A normally dry wash was filled with water and debris in northwest Tucson.
Photo from Arizona Public Media
5
Suizo Road/Cadillac Wash
Up in Pinal County, a couple tried to cross Cadillac Wash, but their car was swept away by the current.
Photo from ABC's KGUN9
Make sure to check your local National Weather Service (NWS) website or social media during the Monsoon season!
Mountain Park Community Church in southern Phoenix suffered from extensive water damage. From: The Arizona Republic
Teenagers swimming inside Indian Bend Wash. From: The Arizona Republic
More about this event:
- Phoenix NWS preliminary report
- Maricopa Flood Control District storm report
- The Arizona Republic newspaper extensive coverage
- Videos of flooded washes and rivers in Tucson from Arizona Daily Star
- National/Local coverage clips:
- NBC : national coverage on September 8, 2014
- CBS : national coverage on September 8, 2014
- CBS : national coverage on September 9, 2014
- ABC-NY : coverage from New York affiliate
- CBS-Phoenix : Mesa aftermath video with residents (2019)
- NBC-Phoenix : Mesa flooding
- NBC-Phoenix : interview with ADOT spokesman Doug Nintzel